A&A 444, 481-493 (2005)
DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361:20053301
A. Fuente1 - R. Neri2 - P. Caselli3
1 - Observatorio Astronómico Nacional (IGN), Campus
Universitario, Apdo. 112, 28803 Alcalá de Henares (Madrid), Spain
2 -
Institut de Radioastronomie Millimétrique, 300 rue de la Piscine, 38406 St. Martin d'Hères Cedex, France
3 -
INAF - Osservatorio Astrofisico de Arcetri, Largo Enrico Fermi 5, 50125 Firenze, Italy
Received 25 April 2005 / Accepted 24 June 2005
Abstract
We report high angular resolution (
at 1.3 mm) observations
of the Class 0 intermediate-mass (IM) protostar NGC 7129-FIRS 2 using the Plateau de Bure
Interferometer. Our observations show the existence of an intense unresolved source in the continuum
at 1.3 mm and 3 mm at the position of the Class 0 object. In addition, compact CH3CN emission is
detected at this position. The high rotational temperature derived from the CH3CN
lines (
K),
as well as the enhanced CH3CN fractional abundance (X(CH3CN)
),
shows the existence of a hot core in this
IM young stellar object. This is to our knowledge the first IM hot core detected so far.
Interferometric maps of the region in the CH3OH 5kk'
4kk'
and D2CO 404
303 lines are also
presented in this paper. The methanol
emission presents two condensations, one associated with the hot core, which
was very intense in the
high upper state energy lines (Eu>100 K), and the other associated with the
bipolar outflow which dominates the emission in the low excitation lines.
Enhanced CH3OH abundances
(X(CH3OH)
- a few 10-7) were measured in both components.
While intense D2CO
emission was detected towards the hot core,
the N2D+
line was not detected in our interferometric observations.
The different behaviors
of D2CO and N2D+ emissions suggest different
formation mechanisms for the two species and different deuteration
processes for H2CO and N2H+ (surface and gas-phase chemistry,
respectively).
Finally, the spectrum of the large bandwidth correlator shows a forest of lines at the hot core position,
revealing that this object is extraordinarily rich
in complex molecules. For deeper insight into the chemistry of complex molecules,
we compared the fractional abundances of the complex O- and N- bearing species
in FIRS 2 with those in hot corinos and massive hot cores. Within the large uncertainty
involved in fractional abundance estimates towards hot cores, we did not detect any variation in
the relative abundances of O- and N-bearing molecules ([CH3CN]/[CH3OH])
with the hot core luminosity. However,
the O-bearing species H2CO and HCOOH seemed to be more abundant in low and intermediate mass
stars than in massive star-forming regions. We propose that this could be the consequence of a different grain
mantle composition in low and massive star-forming regions.
Key words: stars: formation - stars: individual: NGC 7129-FIRS 2 - ISM: abundances - ISM: individual objects: NGC 7129
Hot cores are compact objects near or around protostars characterized by warm temperatures
(Tk >100 K) and
high densities (n> 106 cm-3). These regions are also characterized by a very rich chemistry in complex
molecules (CH3OH, CH3CN, CH3OCHO, CH3OCH3, C2H5CN...).
Hot cores are thought to be associated with high-mass protostars (
)
and
to represent an important phase in their evolution toward ultracompact and compact HII regions. Recently,
regions characterized by warm temperatures and high densities have also been detected in
two low-mass protostars IRAS 16293-2422 (Ceccarelli et al. 2000; Cazaux et al. 2003) and
NGC 1333 IRAS 4A (Bottinelli et al. 2004). Complex molecules typical of hot cores
(e.g. HCOOH, CH3OCHO, CH3CN,
C2H5CN) have also been detected in these objects.
However, the amount of warm material involved, as well as the chemistry, are different in the two classes of objects.
For this reason, the warm regions in the inner envelope of low mass protostars are usually referred to as "hot corinos''.
The formation of complex molecules in hot cores and corinos is poorly
understood. In the standard scheme, neutral molecules (CO, CS...) are
frozen onto dust grains during the cold pre-stellar phase. If the dust
temperature is sufficiently low during this phase, surface hydrogenation
of CO leads to the formation of solid H2CO and CH3OH (e.g. Brown et al.
1988; Charnley et al. 1992; Caselli et al. 1993). Once the star
starts heating the grain surfaces, these molecules (called "parent'' species)
evaporate, enlarging their abundances in the gas phase.
Because of the high temperature and density of hot cores and corinos,
these molecules undergo fast neutral-neutral and ion-neutral reactions producing
a second generation of complex O-bearing
species called "daughter'' molecules at early stages (
104 yr),
such as methyl formate, CH3OCHO.
However, Horn et al. (2004) recently found that the gas-phase reaction sequence
between protonated methanol and formaldehyde, crucial for the gas-phase
formation of methyl formate, does not proceed in their laboratory
experiments. This suggests that surface chemistry is probably also playing a key
role in the formation of this species.
Complex N-bearing species (e.g. CH3CN, CH3CH2CN) are observed
in hot cores and hot corinos. In the chemical scheme of Rodgers
& Charnley (2001), complex N-bearing species are thought to be formed
in the gas phase about 105 yr after the grain mantle
evaporation, but only if the gas temperature is sufficiently large (
300 K).
On the other hand, Caselli et al. (1993) found that large abundances
of ethyl cyanide (X(CH3CH2CN)
10-7, w.r.t. H2) can be
obtained on grain surfaces, if the dust temperature during protostellar
accreting is around 40 K. In the case of lower temperatures (10-20 K),
the CH3CH2CN can still be formed on the surface, but with
reduced abundances (
10-9). Thus, Caselli et al.
(1993) suggest that saturated (or H-rich) complex N-bearing species (such as
ethyl cyanide) are "parent'' species and that they should be observable
as soon as the grain mantles are released in the gas phase upon stellar
heating of the dust. Later on, "H-poor'' N-bearing molecules (e.g. vinyl
cyanide, CH2CHCN) can be formed in the gas phase from the destruction of
CH3CH2CN.
Indeed, if complex species in general are not formed on grain surfaces, there are important problems for understanding the chemical composition of hot corinos: the timescale necessary to convert "parent'' molecules into complex "daughter'' molecules is much longer than the transit time of the gas in hot corinos (a few hundred years). Therefore, it seems that the chemistry of complex molecules must begin on grain surfaces (at least in hot corinos). However, chemists are still far from providing a unique interpretation of the hot core (and corino) chemistry, so, more observational work is needed. In particular, given the large sensitivity of surface and gas-phase chemistry on dust temperature and gas density, it will be extremely important to measure possible variations of complex molecule abundances with the physical characteristics of hot cores, which of course depend on the mass and luminosity of the associated protostar.
In this paper, we present an interferometric study of the hot core
associated with the
Class 0 IM protostar NGC 7129-FIRS 2. With a luminosity
500
and
a mass
5
,
FIRS 2 is very likely the
youngest IM object known at present (Fuente et al. 1998, 2002).
An energetic bipolar molecular outflow with a
quadrupolar morphology is associated with it (Fuente et al. 2001, hereafter Paper I).
Interferometric observations in the continuum at 1mm and the 12CO
line shows that the quadrupolar morphology of the outflow is due to the
superposition of two bipolar molecular outflows FIRS 2-out 1 and FIRS 2-out 2.
FIRS 2-out 1 is associated with
the Class 0 protostar detected as an intense millimeter clump in the
continuum image (MM1 in the nomenclature of Paper I),
while FIRS 2-out 2 is associated with a more evolved infrared star
(FIRS 2 - IR) undetected at millimeter wavelengths.
A quite complete chemical study of this Class 0 IM source was carried out by Fuente et al. (2005) (hereafter Paper II) using the 30 m IRAM telescope. They detected warm CH3CN (Tk>63 K) towards the central position, which constitutes strong evidence of the existence of a hot core in this Class 0 IM object. However, the limited angular resolution of these observations makes it very difficult to distinguish between the hot core emission and those of the outflow and/or the warm envelope. The new results presented in this paper confirm the existence of the hot core associated with FIRS 2 and give a first glance at the chemistry of this object. To our knowledge, FIRS 2 is the first IM hot core detected thus far. The intermediate kinetic temperature and mass of the FIRS 2 hot core are expected to produce a differentiated chemistry and to furnish a link between the low mass and high mass regimes.
The observations presented in this paper correspond to two different
observational projects carried out with the Plateau de Bure
interferometer (PdBI).
The main set of data was observed on March 08, 2003.
The observations were carried out with excellent weather conditions
and counts 5 hr of integration time (on-source) with
6-element array in the A configuration, which provides
the highest angular resolution.
The spectral correlator setup was adjusted to observe
the CH3CN 5
4 line with two contiguous 20 MHz units,
N2D+ 3
2 and D2CO 404
303,
with two separated
20 MHz units; and the remaining units were configured for maximum
continuum sensitivity (see Table 1). These observations show average system
temperatures of 140 K (3 mm) and 250 K (1 mm), a mean atmospheric water
vapour content of 1-2 mm, and were made under seeing
conditions of 0.3 arcsec.
The RF calibrator was 0420-0414, the phase calibrators ordered by
right ascension were 1928+738, 2146+608, and 2309+454, and the flux
calibrator was MWC 349. The precision in the flux densities is better than 20% at 1 mm and better than 10% at 3 mm. Images were created in natural
weighting.
In addition, we present the CH3OH
image observed
during a previous project in November and
December, 1998. The data corresponding to this project were partially
published in Paper I. Details
about the observations are given in Table 1 and Paper I.
![]() |
Figure 1:
Interferometric maps of the Class 0 protostar NGC 7129-FIRS 2 in the
continuum at 1 mm and 3 mm, and the following molecular lines: CH3CN 5
|
| Open with DEXTER | |
![]() |
Figure 2: Continuum visibilities at 92 GHz and 230 GHz vs. projected baselines in units of wavelength. In the bottom panel we show the 92 GHz and the 230 GHz visibilities together. The 92 GHz visibilities were scaled by a factor of 10.5 to match the 230 GHz ones. The perfect match between the 92 GHz and 230 GHz visibilities suggests that both emissions arise in the same region as expected in the case of dust thermal emission. |
| Open with DEXTER | |
Table 1: Observations with the Plateau de Bure Interferometer (PdBI).
We modeled the
visibilities for deeper insight into the source structure.
In Fig. 2 we show the 92 GHz and 230 GHz visibilities vs. projected baselines
in units of wavelength. The 92 GHz visibilities scaled by a factor of
10.5 match the 230 GHz visibilities perfectly. This suggests that both
emissions are arising exactly in the same region. The spectral index is
.
That the 3 mm and 1.3 mm emissions arise in the
same region and the spectral index is larger than 2 is consistent with dust thermal
emission. We used the high-angular resolution 1.3 mm image to model the
continuum emission. Several models (elliptical Gaussian, disk,
,
,
and an elliptical Gaussian+point source) were
used to fit the visibilities. The best fit was obtained with the
elliptical Gaussian+point source model. The HPFW of the elliptical Gaussian is
AU and the flux 0.43 Jy. The point source has a flux of 0.13 Jy.
The total flux of the compact 1.3 mm component is
0.56 Jy, which implies a total
(dust + gas) mass of 2
assuming a standard dust temperature of 100 K and a dust
emissivity
(1300/
(
m)) cm2 g-1.
Considering the uncertainty in the value of the dust temperature, which could
range between 50 K and 300 K, this mass is accurate within a factor of 4.
We speculate about the possibility that the point source is an accretion disk. In this case,
the mass of the disk would be
0.3-0.8
.
This value is 30 times higher
than that found by Fuente et al. (2003) in the Herbig Be star R Mon, but it is similar to
the one found by Rodríguez et al. (2005) in the Class 0 low-mass protostar IRAS 16293-2422B.
Thus if our assumption is confirmed,
the difference in the disk occurrence and masses between IM and low mass stars
would be related to a short timescale for the disk dissipation
instead of to
differences in the first stages of the star formation. This interpretation
is in line with Fuente et al. (2003).
Table 2: Gaussian fits to the line and continuum emission.
![]() |
Figure 3: Comparison between the single-dish (thin histograms) and interferometric (thick histograms) spectra towards the hot core position. The interferometric spectrum was scaled for an easier comparison. Note that we recovered all the flux for the CH3CN line with the highest upper state energy. |
| Open with DEXTER | |
Because of the rotational structure of CH3CN, one can observe several
lines at different energies very close in frequency.
In Fig. 3 we show the interferometric spectrum
of the CH3CN
line compared to the single-dish spectrum reported
in Paper II. The interferometer has recovered 100% of the flux of the
highest upper state energy component (Eu=124 K) (see Fig. 3).
However, only 37% of the flux of the lowest energy
component (Eu=13 K) was recovered (see Fig. 3).
This suggests that while the emission of the low energy CH3CN lines
mainly arises in the cooler and more extended envelope, the emission of the high
energy lines arises entirely in the hot core.
In addition to the CH3CN K-ladder we also detected the CH313CN
50
40 line which allows us
to estimate the opacity of the CH3CN line.
The CH3CN column density was estimated using the rotational
diagram technique. The low energy lines are expected to
be optically thick in the hot core. This is confirmed by our
interferometric observations. In particular,
we measure I(CH3CN 5
0)/I(CH313CN 50
40)
2.4,
which implies an opacity
25 for the main isotope line
assuming 12C/13C = 70. We
corrected by the opacity effect and derived
K and a beam averaged column density
N(CH3CN)
cm-2for the hot core component
using the 5
and 55
45 lines.
The derived rotation temperature is in agreement, within the uncertainties,
with the one
derived from single dish data (Fuente et al. 2005). Since
the low energy lines are optically thick in the hot core, we think that this
agreement is fortuitous and due to the addition of two uncertainties
which shift the estimated column
density in opposite directions, the contribution of extended emission in the
single-dish beam, and the opacity effect.
From our interferometric observations,
we obtained X(CH3CN)
in the 2
hot core in FIRS 2 assuming a source size of 0.72
0.52
(see Table 5).
This fractional abundance is similar to that measured in
massive hot cores and slightly larger than those derived in hot corinos.
For comparison, we estimated the CH3CN abundance
in the cooler and extended envelope. For this aim, we
subtracted the emission of the compact component from the single-dish spectrum and
analyzed the result using a rotational diagram. The opacity effect
is expected to be less important in the low density envelope than in the hot
core. We derived
K and a beam averaged column density of
cm-2(
). Using the H2 column density derived from single-dish continuum
observations by Fuente et al. (2001), we estimated a
CH3CN fractional abundance of
in the extended
component, i.e. about 3 orders of magnitude lower than in the compact component.
Summarizing, our CH3CN interferometric data show the existence of a compact
(
AU) source characterized by a high kinetic gas temperature
(>50 K) and enhanced CH3CN abundance (X(CH3CN)
)
in the Class 0 IM protostar FIRS 2. This constitutes definite proof of the existence of a hot core
in this IM protostar which, to our knowledge, is the first IM hot core detected so far.
In Fig. 3 we compare the interferometric
spectra for the hot core and outflow components with
the single-dish spectrum at the central position.
The two components present differences in their kinematics and excitation
conditions.
The emission of the CH3OH lines towards the hot core is centered at a
velocity -
km s-1, while the emission
of the outflow component is centered at -
km s-1.
The 12CO 2
1 and SiO 2
1 maps of the
outflow FIRS 2-out 1 reported in Paper II show that
this velocity, -
km s-1, is characteristic
of the high velocity bullet R1,
reinforcing our association of this emission with the bipolar outflow.
![]() |
Figure 4: Rotational diagram of CH3OH towards the hot core and the outflow condensation. Note that the rotation temperature towards the hot core is much higher than towards the outflow condensation. |
| Open with DEXTER | |
Different excitation conditions characterize the hot core and outflow components.
This is clearly seen when one compares the relative intensities of
the high and low energy lines in the methanol spectra towards the
two studied positions.
All the CH3OH lines have similar intensities towards the hot core.
However, high energy lines are a factor
5 weaker than the low energy
ones towards the outflow position (see Fig. 3). We
derived the rotation temperature and the beam averaged CH3OH column density
for the hot core using the rotational diagram technique
(see Fig. 4), and obtained
K and
N(CH3OH) =
cm-2.
This temperature is quite high compared the one obtained from the
CH3CN lines.
Similar to the case of CH3CN, the low energy lines are very likely
optically thick, and the derived rotation temperature is an upper limit to
the actual one. To have an estimate of the uncertainty due to
the unknown rotation temperature in the CH3OH column density,
we calculated the CH3OH column density
from the flux of the 5
line (Eu=104 K)
assuming
K. We obtain N(CH3OH) =
cm-2.
Thus, we consider that our beam averaged column density estimate
is accurate within a factor of 3.
Assuming
K, the derived CH3OH fractional abundance
is
in the hot core. This abundance is
similar to that measured in the
prototypical massive hot core OMC1.
For comparison, we estimated the rotation temperature and methanol
column density for the outflow condensation (see Fig. 4), and obtained
K and N(CH3OH) =
cm-2. The low rotational
temperature of this component supports our interpretation of it being associated with
the outflow (postshocked material) instead of with the hot core.
We did not detect a millimeter continuum
counterpart for this condensation in our interferometric 1mm map. In principle,
this could be a sensitivity problem. From our interferometric image and
assuming
K, we derive a
upper limit of
0.01
for the mass of the condensation associated with the methanol clump. This would imply
X(CH3OH) >
in this clump. We can alternatively think that this clump is not the result of a hydrogen density enhancement at this position.
For example,
it could be produced by a local enhancement of the CH3OH abundance
because of the shocks associated with the bipolar outflow.
To estimate the methanol abundance
in this case, we calculated the H2 column density from the
single-dish 13CO observations
reported in Paper II. At the velocities of the bullet R1, the 13CO column
density averaged in the 30 m beam is
cm-2.
If we assume uniform distribution of the
molecular gas in the beam, we find that the CH3OH abundance
is similar to that of 13CO for which we assume a standard value of
10-6. Obviously, this is an upper limit to the actual abundance since we
expect some clumpiness. Thus, the CH3OH abundance in the outflow condensation
could be larger than in the hot core and reach values close to 10-6.
This high value of the methanol abundance is consistent with those
found in the molecular bullets associated
with low-mass bipolar outflows (see e.g. Bachiller & Pérez-Gutierrez 1997).
In addition to the CH3OH lines, the spectrum towards the hot core show several lines that are weaker towards the outflow condensation. We identified these lines as belonging to the complex molecules CH3OCH3 and C2H5CN. We also have a tentative detection of the sulphuretted species 34SO2. The detection of complex saturated molecules corroborates the existence of a hot core in this source and reveals the rich and complex chemistry associated with it.
Our previous single-dish spectrum was too noisy to detect this wide emission (Paper II). Recently, we took a good signal-to-noise ratio spectrum to compare with the interferometric observations (see Fig. 3). The single-dish spectrum shows two components, a narrow one at the velocity of the ambient cloud (already detected in Paper II), which is completely missed in our interferometric observations, and a wide one with a linewidth similar to that of the PdB spectrum. Even in this wide component the interferometer recovers only 50% of the flux, suggesting that part of them arises in a more extended area.
A narrow and wide components with linewidths similar to those of D2CO were also detected in the single dish spectra of the H2CO lines (Paper II). In Paper II, we separately mapped the narrow and wide components. These maps revealed that both components are associated with the outflow. While the wide component arises in the jet, the emission of the narrow component was more intense in the interface between the jet and the molecular cloud suggesting that it is tracing the molecular gas being swept up by the jet. We propose that the missed flux in our interferometric D2CO image is probably arising in a more extended component associated with the bipolar outflow similar to the case of H2CO.
Our interferometric image
shows that, in addition to the extended component, there is
an intense and compact D2CO component associated
with the hot core.
We estimated the D2CO abundance in this component
assuming
K and obtained
N(D2CO) = 3.5
1014 cm-2 and X(D2CO)
.
This fractional abundance is a factor of
2 higher than that derived
in Paper II for the whole envelope.
![]() |
Figure 5: Spectra of the upper side band (USB) and lower side band (LSB) of the 1 mm receiver obtained in our PdBI observations with our best guess for line identifications. For clarity, we divided the molecular species in three groups. The first group is formed by the more reliable identifications and S18O. Beginning from the top, in the first line of panels we compare the observed spectra with the synthesized ones taking only this first group into account. In the second line, we add CH3OCHO-A/E and show the obtained synthesized spectra. Inclusion of these compounds improves agreement with the observational data. However, the large CH3OCHO-A/E abundance we derived from these observations raise some questions about this identification. In the third line of panels, we show the synthesized spectra after adding some other exotic compounds. The last line shows the residual spectra after subtracting our fit. Note that agreement between the synthesized and observed one is very good in the USB, but some lines remain unidentified in the LSB. |
| Open with DEXTER | |
Table 3: USB - 2.4 MHz.
Obviously, this identification procedure entails some ambiguity. We classified the species according to the reliability of their identification in two groups that are differentiated in Table 5. The first group contains the most reliable identifications. In these cases, the observed frequencies are in total agreement with those calculated for these species. Moreover, the synthesized spectrum matches the observed one quite well (see top panel of Fig. 5). Finally, the derived fractional abundances are within the range of abundances measured for these species in hot cores. Within this group, we have OCS, 13CS, C2H5CN, c-C3D, D2CO, HCOOH, and C2H5OH in the USB and C2H5OH, C3HD in the LSB. The lines of the first group species are indicated by bold characters in Tables 3 and 4. The derived column densities and fractional abundances are shown in Table 5.
We put the complex molecules CH3OCHO-A and CH3OCHO-E (methyl formate)
in the second group. Several lines of these species were detected in the USB
and LSB (see second panels in Fig. 5).
However, the derived fractional abundances in NGC 7129-FIRS 2 are unexpectedly high
compared to those measured in hot corinos and massive hot cores (see Table 5).
One possibility is that the
rotation temperature is higher than was assumed. To estimate the uncertainty
due to the poorly known rotation temperature, we repeated the column
density calculations with
K. The derived abundance is an order
of magnitude lower and then agrees with
that derived in IRAS 16293. This high rotation temperature could be
explained if this complex
molecule arises in an inner and hotter region than CH3CN.
If methyl formate cannot be produced in the gas phase, as
suggested by the laboratory results of Horn et al. (2004), our findings
may imply that this species is formed on grain surfaces and that its
binding energy is larger than that of CH3CN, thus requiring
larger dust temperatures to desorb.
Table 4: LSB - 2.4 MHz.
The rarer isotope S18O has also been included in the group of uncertain
identifications. We have only one line of this molecule,
S18O 98
88 at 228.272 GHz, and the derived S18O abundance
is unexpectedly high. In this case we could have a misidentification.
There is a CH3OCHO-A line
at 228.270 GHz, which could be an alternative
identification of the tentative S18O line if the methyl formate abundance
is unexpectedly high.
Table 5: Fractional Abundances in the hot core of NGC 7129-FIRS 2 and comparison with other hot cores.
The most uncertain identifications are C2H3CHO, CH3CHO-A, HCCCHO,
and NO2. The observed frequencies are in agreement with those of C2H3CHO,
CH3CHO-A, and HCCCHO lines if the emission arises in gas at a velocity
km s-1. This velocity is coincident with
that of the bullet R1 (see Paper I) but is shifted by
5 km s-1from that of the molecular cloud. Similarly, the fit to the USB spectrum improves if we include
a high excitation methanol line (see Table 3)
emitting at the velocities -5 and -20 km s-1. These velocities are within
the range of velocities associated with this Class 0 protostar but
are shifted from that of the ambient cloud.
NO2 is not a common molecule in hot cores,
and the three lines observed in the spectrum are overlapped with others of more common
hot core species. We have kept it in the table because
its inclusion improves the fit to the observed spectrum.
In Fig. 5 we show the synthesized USB and LSB spectra
assuming the molecular column densities listed in Table 3. The
fit is quite good for the USB. However, it is poor for the LSB, where
we still have 4 unidentified lines. This is quite frustrating taking into account
that they are the most intense lines in this subband. The frequencies of
the unidentified lines are 228 467(
5), 228 434(
5), 228 245(
5),
and 228 232(
5) MHz, and we do not have any good candidates
for them. There is a line of vibrationally excited DC3N at the frequency
of 228 467.44 GHz. Emission of vibrationally excited HC3N has been
detected in massive hot cores (see e.g. Wyrowski et al. 1999).
However, if this identification were correct, we would expect to see
a vibrationally excited HC3N line at least ten times more intense at
a frequency of 228 303 MHz, which was not detected. For the line at 228 434 MHz our best
candidate is glycoaldehyde (CH2(OH)CHO), which has already
been observed in the interstellar medium (Hollis et al. 2004). However, the upper state energy of
the line at 228 434 MHz is too high (>1400 K) to be detectable in this source.
The line at 228 245 MHz could be propadienone (CH2CCO), but in this case we should
have detected other lines of this compound in the same spectrum. Finally, our best
candidate for the line at 228 232 MHz is cyclopropenone (C3H2O), and
this molecule has never been detected in space. Since we have only
one observable line in our spectra, we cannot confirm this detection.
In addition to the lines detected in the wide-band spectrum shown in Fig. 5, in Table 5 we also include the column densities derived for CH3OCH3 and 34SO2, the species detected in the CH3OH spectrum shown in Fig. 3. Since we have only one line for these species, the derived column density is also uncertain.
In Table 5 we list the derived abundances of the molecules detected in the hot core towards FIRS 2. A first look at the table reveals that FIRS 2 is rich in deuterated species (D2CO, c-C3D and c-C3HD), sulphuretted compounds (13CS, OCS), and complex O- and N- molecules (HCOOH, C2H5OH, C2H5CN). Taking the large uncertainty in the estimated fractional abundances into account, we centered our discussion on the most reliable identifications, i.e., the first group in Table 5.
![]() |
Figure 6:
Single-dish spectra of the H2CO 312
|
| Open with DEXTER | |
Another phenomenon which boosts the deuterium fractionation is the freeze-out of neutral species, in particular the abundant O and CO, which are efficient destruction partners of H3+ and H2D+ in the gas phase. Their freeze out, known to happen in dense cold clouds (Williams et al. 1998; Caselli et al. 1999; Kramer et al. 1999; Bergin et al. 2002; Tafalla et al. 2002), further enhances the H2D+/H3+ abundance ratio (because of the enhanced formation rate of H2D+, and the reduced destruction rates for H2D+ and H3+) and the consequent transfer of the deuteron to gas-phase species (Caselli et al. 2002a; Bacmann et al. 2003; Crapsi et al. 2005). Once CO is highly depleted, multiple deuterated forms of H3+ can easily be produced (Roberts et al. 2003; Walmsley et al. 2004). Indeed, large abundances of H2D+ and D2H+ have been measured toward two pre-stellar cores (Caselli et al. 2003; Vastel et al. 2004). This has the consequence of enhancing the gaseous D/H ratio to values around 0.1, four orders of magnitude larger than the cosmic D abundance, which allows an efficient deuteration on grain surfaces (Tielens 1983; Charnley et al. 1997; Stantcheva & Herbst 2003).
We detected the deuterated species D2CO, c-C3D, and
c-C3HD towards FIRS 2. Moreover, the D2CO
interferometric image shows that the D2CO emission is strongly
peaked towards the hot core position. Recent theoretical and
observational research suggests that
the abundance of the non-deuterated species H2CO is enhanced
by more than 2 orders of magnitude in the inner
region of the envelope, where the dust temperature is higher than 100 K
(Maret et al. 2004). The size of this region (
100 AU) is similar
to that derived for the D2CO emission from the linewidth of the D2CO line.
Assuming that evaporation is also the origin of D2CO,
the [D2CO]/[H2CO] would tell us about the gaseous D/H ratio
during the pre-stellar phase of the parent clump.
Unfortunately, we have no interferometric observations of
H2CO and cannot derive an accurate [D2CO]/[H2CO]
ratio in the hot core. Trying to get an estimate of the deuteration
degree of formaldehyde, we compared the single dish spectra
of the D2CO 404
303
and H2CO 312
211 lines (see Fig. 6).
Both lines have
similar excitation conditions and frequency.
The line intensity ratio in the narrow component is
lower by a factor of 2 than in the wide component suggesting a
higher [D2CO]/[H2CO] ratio in the hot core. Assuming
the same physical conditions for D2CO and H2CO, we
derived [D2CO]/[H2CO]
in the hot core.
This value is similar to the one found in pre-stellar cores
and low-mass protostars (Caselli et al. 2002a; Bacmann et al. 2003; Ceccarelli et al. 2001; Loinard et al. 2003),
and it implies large D/H ratios during
the cold pre-stellar phase (D/H
0.5, see Caselli et al. 2002ab;
Stantcheva & Herbst 2003).
In contrast to D2CO, we have not detected N2D+ in our interferometric observations. It is interesting to note that, whereas the deuteration of N2H+ is a gas-phase process (which proceeds from the reaction between N2 and H2D+), the formation of D2CO seems to require surface chemistry (Ceccarelli et al. 2002). Therefore, our result is not surprising. In fact, as stated above, the deuteration in the gas phase is efficient only if the gas temperature is lower than, say, 30 K. Thus, in a hot core, we do not expect to see N2D+. Moreover, in hot cores, where icy grain mantles evaporates, CO and H2O molecules are abundant in the gas phase, and they efficiently destroy N2H+ (and N2D+), so that one does not expect to see large abundances of N2H+ either. The non-detection of N2D+ in the hot core associated with FIRS 2 confirms the interpretation given in Paper II that N2D+ arises mainly in the cool envelope, and constitutes indirect proof of this chemical scheme. On the other hand, the large D2CO/H2CO abundance ratio observed in the same position can be easily explained if the deuterium fractionation of formaldehyde happened on grain surfaces during the cold pre-stellar phase, and if icy mantles have recently evaporated, so that gas phase chemistry did not have enough time to reduce the abundance of the deuterated "parent'' species.
Theoretical models predict that the relative abundance of
the N-bearing and O-bearing complex molecules is dependent on the hot
core temperature (Caselli et al. 1993; Rodgers & Charnley 2001).
The luminosity of FIRS 2 is a factor >10 larger than those of the two
low mass hot corinos detected so far and a factor
200 lower than that of the massive protostar creating the Orion hot core.
The intermediate kinetic temperature of the FIRS 2 hot core is expected to
produce a differentiated chemistry of complex molecules.
In order to better show the dependence of the complex molecule
abundances on the protostellar luminosity, in Table 5
we compare the observed abundances towards FIRS 2
with those measured in prototypical hot corinos and massive hot cores.
The luminosity of the objects listed in Table 5 varies by 4 orders of
magnitude, thus one expects to detect some chemical differences
between these hot cores.
However, comparing abundances between different hot cores (corinos)
is difficult. First of all, since massive stars are usually located farther
from the Sun than their low- and intermediate-mass counterparts,
the abundances are derived on different spatial
scales. The fractional abundances shown in Table 5
are averaged values in regions with sizes ranging
from
0.002 pc in NGC1333-IRAS 4A to
0.32 pc in OMC1 and G327. These sizes are given by the
angular resolution of the current instrumentation at the
hot core distance. Thus, the derived abundances in massive hot cores
would be severely underestimated in the case of sizes similar
to those of hot corinos. On the other hand, we can have several hot
cores in the studied region, especially
in massive star-forming regions where clustering is more
important and are located at greater distances. In order to minimize
these problems, we normalized the studied abundances
to those of the parent species.
As a first step, we normalized all the molecular
abundances to that of H2CO and CH3OH.
These species are thought to be
the "parent'' molecules of complex O-bearing species,
although there is some doubt in the particular case of
methyl formate (Horn et al. 2004).
In Fig. 7a, we show the relative
abundances of HCOOH, CH3OH, CH3CN, and C2H5CN with
respect to H2CO as a function of the luminosity.
Since we have no interferometric observations of H2CO
in FIRS 2, we estimated the H2CO abundance
assuming [D2CO]/[H2CO] = 0.014.
A clear trend is observed in the relative abundance of CH3OH, CH3CN, and
C2H5CN with respect to H2CO as a function of the stellar luminosity
(Fig. 7a). The abundance of all these molecules increases by a factor of
10
from NGC 1333-IRAS 4A (L=14
)
to OMC1 (L=104
).
This trend does not present significant differences between O- and N-bearing
molecules. Contrary to these molecules, the [HCOOH]/[H2CO] ratio
does not present any systematic behavior.
![]() |
Figure 7: Relative abundances of the complex O- and N-bearing molecules as a function of the protostellar luminosity for the objects listed in Table 3. |
| Open with DEXTER | |
In Fig. 7b we plot the abundances of the same molecules normalized to CH3OH. Different behaviors are found for the different molecules. The [CH3CN]/[CH3OH] ratio does not present any systematic trend with the protostellar luminosity, although the dispersion in the values is quite high. The same remains true for C2H5CN and probably for C2H5OH, though we only have 3 points for C2H5OH. This suggests that the ratio between O- and N-bearing complex molecules does not depend strongly on the protostellar luminosity, contrary to expectations from theoretical models. However, the relative abundance of HCOOH seems to decrease by 2 orders of magnitude from NGC 1333-IRAS4 A to G327.3. Thus, the relative abundances of HCOOH to those of CH3OH, CH3CN, C2H5CN, and C2H5OH seem to decrease with the protostellar luminosity.
We propose that the increase in CH3OH/H2CO
(as well as CH3OH/HCOOH),
CH3CN/H2CO, and C2H5CN/H2CO with
stellar luminosity is most likely due to
differences in the grain mantle composition between low and massive
star-forming regions. Indeed, differences in the initial conditions,
in particular gas density and dust temperature, are known to
strongly affect surface chemistry. For example, Caselli et al. (1993)
found that complex N-bearing species are more easily formed if the
dust grain temperature (
)
is about 40 K, during the collapse phase.
Although such temperature can be found in a significant fraction
of a collapsing massive clump surrounding a massive young stellar
object (Fontani et al. 2002), this is not the case for low mass
cores. Therefore, the observed trend (at least for N-bearing species)
is consistent with theoretical predictions. But Caselli et al.
(1993) also found that at
K, methanol is not efficiently
formed on the surface because it requires the volatile H to stick
on the grain surface (see also Charnley et al. 1992; van der Tak
et al. 2000). Thus, the observed CH3OH/H2CO increase
with stellar luminosity is not well understood, unless another
surface formation mechanism for methanol (besides the CO hydrogenation)
becomes important in the warmer high mass clumps, e.g. OH+CH3(see also discussion in Pontoppidan et al. 2003).
However, this conclusion is only based on 4 sources and has to be confirmed with
a larger and more complete sample. Observational bias, such as
the different spatial scale for the different objects, can contribute to
this trend if the spatial extension of the emission of the
observed molecules is different.
In Fig. 7c, we compare only the N-bearing molecules. The [C2H5CN]/ [CH3CN] ratio remains quite constant with a dispersion of about a factor <10 between all the sources. This uniform [C2H5CN]/ [CH3CN] ratio suggests that the chemistry of both compounds is linked. Indeed, these two molecules have a common parent species: C2N (see e.g. Fig. 7 in Caselli et al. 1993)
Our interferometric observations of CH3CN, CH3OH,
D2CO, and N2D+ provides information on the structure and
chemistry of this object. While the CH3CN emission arises mainly
in the hot core, the CH3OH emission has a component associated with
the bipolar outflow. The CH3CN abundance is
in the
hot core, which is about 3 orders of
magnitude larger than in the cool envelope.
The methanol abundance is enhanced (>
-a few 10-7) in
the hot core and the outflow components. However, the rotation
temperature is higher in the hot core than in the outflow, revealing very
different physical conditions and probably a different CH3OH
desorption mechanism for the two components.
The doubly deuterated formaldehyde also presents enhanced
abundances in the hot core. We estimate a [D2CO]/[H2CO]
0.14,
which is 4 orders of magnitude larger than the cosmic D
abundance and similar to those found in pre-stellar clumps and
low-mass protostars. The enhanced [D2CO]/[H2CO] abundance in the hot
core suggests that grain surface chemistry is responsible of the deuteration process
of H2CO. In contrast to the high deuteration degree of formaldehyde, we did not
detect N2D+ in the hot core. This is consistent with the chemical scheme
in which, while the deuteration of H2CO requires surface chemistry,
the deuteration of N2H+ is a gas-phase process.
A large number of molecular lines have been detected in our interferometric spectra
towards FIRS 2. Most of these lines are identified as belonging to deuterated
(D2CO, c-C3D and c-C3HD), sulphuretted (13CS, OCS), and complex
O-/N-bearing species (HCOOH, C2H5OH, C2H5CN). Deuterated
species, whose deuteration requires surface chemistry such as D2CO,
present enhanced
abundances in the warm regions associated with low-mass
protostars. Loinard et al. (2003) searched for the doubly deuterated form of
formaldehyde (D2CO) in a large
sample of young stellar objects. D2CO was detected in all low-mass protostars
with [D2CO]/[H2CO]
ratios of 2-40%. On the other hand, no detection was obtained
towards more massive protostars, where [D2CO] [H2CO] < 0.5%.
This is consistent with the results reported by Turner (1990), who
detected D2CO in Orion and measured [D2CO]/[H2CO]
0.003.
If the hot cores associated with massive stars are older or
significantly denser than those surrounding low-mass objects, gas
phase chemistry could have had time to re-set the deuterium
fractionation to values close to the cosmic D/H ratio. An alternative
explanation is that the gas temperature of the material
accreting high mass protostars is higher than 30 K (Fontani et al. 2002),
so that the deuterium fractionation efficiency in
the gas phase is strongly reduced already before the hot core phase.
The sulphuretted and complex compounds are characteristic of hot cores in both the low-mass and the high-mass regimes. FIRS 2 is the first IM hot core detected thus far and presents a unique opportunity to study the link between the chemistry of hot corinos and massive hot cores. We have compared the abundances of complex molecules in FIRS 2 with those in hot corinos and the massive hot cores OMC1 and G327.3-0.6. Contrary to model predictions, we did not detect any dependence of the O-/N-complex molecules ratio on the protostellar luminosity. However, we detected differences between the behavior of the O-bearing species with the stellar luminosity. While H2CO and HCOOH are more abundant in low luminosity sources, CH3OH seems to be more abundant in massive objects. We propose that this could be due to a different mantle composition in the two kinds of region, caused by different physical conditions (mainly gas density and dust temperature) during the pre-stellar and accretion phase. However, this could also be due to other factors, such as the different spatial scale of the observations or a possible contribution of the shocked gas associated with the bipolar outflow to the emission of these molecules. Differences in the hot core ages and/or cloud initial conditions could also produce these differences. The detection and detailed study of more intermediate-mass hot cores are necessary to reach firm conclusions.
Acknowledgements
This work was partially supported by the Spanish DGICYT under grant AYA2003-07584 and Spanish DGI/SEPCT under grant ESP2003-04957. PC acknowledges support from the MIUR grant "Dust and molecules in astrophysical environments''. We are also grateful to the anonymous referee for his/her fruitful comments.