A&A 421, 623-642 (2004)
DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361:20035775
A. A. Kaas1,2 - G. Olofsson2 - S. Bontemps3,2 - P. André4 - L. Nordh2 - M. Huldtgren2 - T. Prusti5 - P. Persi6 - A. J. Delgado7 - F. Motte4 - A. Abergel8 - F. Boulanger8 - M. Burgdorf14 - M. M. Casali9 - C. J. Cesarsky4 - J. Davies10 - E. Falgarone11 - T. Montmerle12 - M. Perault11 - J. L. Puget8 - F. Sibille13
1 - Nordic Optical Telescope, Apdo 474, 38700 Santa Cruz de La Palma, Spain
2 - Stockholm Observatory, Roslagstullsbacken 21, 10691 Stockholm,
Sweden
3 - Observatoire de Bordeaux, BP 89, 33270 Floirac, France
4 - Service d'Astrophysique, CEA Saclay, 91191
Gif-sur-Yvette, France
5 - Research and Scientific Support Department of ESA, Postbus 229,
2200 AG Noordwijk, The Netherlands
6 - Instituto Astrofisica Spaziale e Fisica Cosmica, CNR, Rome, Italy
7 - Instituto de Astrofísica de Andalucia, Granada, Spain
8 - IAS, Université Paris XI, 91405 Orsay, France
9 - Royal Observatory, Blackford Hill, Edinburgh EH9 3HJ, UK
10 - Joint Astronomy Centre, 660 N. A'Ohoku Place, University
Park, Hilo, HI 96720, USA
11 - ENS Radioastronomie, 24 Rue Lhomond, 75231 Paris, France
12 - Laboratoire d'Astrophysique de Grenoble, 38041 Grenoble Cedex,
France
13 - Observatoire de Lyon, 69230 Saint Genis Laval, France
14 - SIRTF Science Center, California Institute of Technology,
220-6, Pasadena, CA 91125
Received 1 December 2003 / Accepted 18 March 2004
Abstract
We present results from an ISOCAM survey in the two broad band
filters LW2 (5-8.5
m) and LW3 (12-18
m) of a 0.13 square degree
coverage of the Serpens Main Cloud Core. A total of 392 sources were
detected in the 6.7
m band and 139 in the 14.3
m band to a
limiting sensitivity of
2 mJy. We identified 53 Young Stellar
Objects (YSOs) with mid-IR excess from the single colour index
[14.3/6.7],
and 8 additional YSOs from the
H-K/K-m6.7 diagram.
Only 32 of these 61 sources were previously known to be YSO candidates.
Only about 50% of the mid-IR excess sources show excesses in the near-IR
J-H/H-K diagram.
In the 48 square arcmin field covering the central Cloud Core the
Class I/Class II number ratio is 19/18, i.e. about 10 times larger than
in other young embedded clusters such as
Ophiuchi or Chamaeleon.
The mid-IR fluxes of the Class I and flat-spectrum sources are found to
be on the average larger than those of Class II sources. Stellar
luminosities are estimated for the Class II sample, and its luminosity
function is compatible with a coeval population of about 2 Myr which
follows a three segment power-law IMF. For this age about 20% of the
Class IIs are found to be young brown dwarf candidates. The YSOs are in
general strongly clustered, the Class I sources more than the Class II
sources, and there is an indication of sub-clustering. The sub-clustering
of the protostar candidates has a spatial scale of 0.12 pc. These
sub-clusters are found along the NW-SE oriented ridge and in very good
agreement with the location of dense cores traced by millimeter data. The
smallest clustering scale for the Class II sources is about 0.25 pc,
similar to what was found for
Ophiuchi. Our data show evidence
that star formation in Serpens has proceeded in several phases, and that
a "microburst'' of star formation has taken place very recently, probably
within the last 105 yrs.
Key words: stars: formation - stars: pre-main-sequence - stars: luminosity function, mass function - stars: low-mass, brown dwarfs - ISM: individual objects: Serpens Cloud Core
The youngest stellar clusters are found deeply embedded in the molecular
clouds from which they form. There are several reasons why very young
clusters are particularly interesting for statistical studies such as mass
functions and spatial distributions.
Because mass segregation and loss of low mass members due to dynamical
evolution has not had time to develop significantly for ages
yrs (Scalo 1998), the stellar IMF can in principle be found for the
complete sample, at least for sufficiently rich clusters.
For ages
yrs the spatial distribution should
in gross reflect the distribution at birth, which gives important input
to the studies of cloud fragmentation and cluster formation. Only in the
youngest regions of low mass star formation do we find the co-existence
of newly born stars and pre-stellar clumps, which allows one to compare
the mass functions of the different evolutionary stages. Low mass stars
are more luminous when they are young, being either in their
protostellar phase or contracting down the Hayashi track, which
permits probing lower limiting masses.
Severe cloud extinction, however, requires sensitive IR mapping at high
spatial resolution to sample the stellar population of embedded
clusters.
ISOCAM, the camera aboard the ISO satellite (Kessler et al. 1996), provided
sensitivity and relatively high spatial resolution in the mid-IR (Cesarsky et al. 1996).
The two broad band filters LW2 (5-8.5
m) and LW3 (12-18
m),
designed to avoid the silicate features at 10 and 20
m, were selected
to sample the mid-IR Spectral Energy Distribution (SED) of Young Stellar
Objects (YSOs) in different evolutionary phases. According to the current
empirical picture for the early evolution of low mass stars
(Lada 1987; André & Montmerle 1994; Adams et al. 1987; André et al. 1993),
newborn YSOs can be observationally classified into 4 main evolutionary
classes. Class 0 objects are in the deeply embedded main accretion phase
(
104 yrs), and have measured circumstellar envelope masses
larger than their estimated central stellar masses, with overall SEDs
resembling cold blackbodies and peaking in the far-IR. Class I sources
(
yrs) are observationally characterised by a broad SED with a
rising spectral index
towards
longer wavelengths (
)
in the mid-IR. The Class II
sources spend some 106 yrs in a phase where most of the circumstellar
matter is distributed in an optically thick disk, displaying broad SEDs
with
.
At
the disk turns optically thin, and the sources evolve into the
(
yrs) Class III stage where the mid-IR imprints of a disk
eventually disappear. A normal stellar photosphere has
.
Thus, while Class 0 objects are not favourably traced by mid-IR
photometry, they are expected to be rare. At the other extreme, Class III
sources cannot generally be distinguished using mid-IR photometry
since most of them have SEDs similar to normal stellar photospheres.
But mid-IR photometry from two broad bands, as obtained in this study with
ISOCAM, is highly efficient when it comes to detection and classification
of Class I and Class II sources. Thus, considering the fact that these
latter objects constitute the major fraction of the youngest YSOs, the
ISOCAM surveys provide a better defined sample for statistical studies
than e.g. near-IR surveys for regions with very recent star formation
(see Prusti 1999).
This paper presents the results from an ISOCAM survey of
0.13 square
degrees around the Serpens Cloud Core in two broad bands centred at 6.7 and
14.3
m. This cloud, located at
and
at a distance of
pc (Straizys et al. 1996; Festin 1998), comprises
a deeply embedded, very young cluster with large and spatially inhomogeneous
cloud extinction, exceeding 50 mag of visual extinction. Only a few
sources are detected in the optical (Hartigan & Lada 1985; Giovannetti et al. 1998; Gómez de Castro et al. 1988). Serpens contains
one of the richest known collection of Class 0 objects
(Casali et al. 1993; Davis et al. 1999; Hurt & Barsony 1996; Wolf-Chase et al. 1998), an indication that this cluster is young and
active. On-going star formation is also evident from the presence of several
molecular outflows (Herbst et al. 1997; Davis et al. 1999; Huard et al. 1997; Bally & Lada 1983; White et al. 1995), pre-stellar
condensations seen as sub-mm sources (Casali et al. 1993; Testi & Sargent 1998; Williams & Myers 2000; McMullin et al. 1994), a
far-IR source (FIRS1) possibly associated with a non-thermal triple radio
continuum source (Rodriguez et al. 1989; Eiroa & Casali 1989; Curiel et al. 1993), a FUor-like object (Hodapp et al. 1996),
and jets and knots in the 2.1
m H2 line (Herbst et al. 1997; Eiroa et al. 1997).
Investigations of the stellar content have been made with near-IR surveys
(Strom et al. 1976; Giovannetti et al. 1998; Kaas 1999a; Churchwell & Koornneef 1986; Sogawa et al. 1997; Eiroa & Casali 1992), identifying YSOs using
different criteria, such as e.g. near-IR excesses, association with
nebulosities, and variability.
In this paper we identify new cluster members, characterize the YSOs into Class I, flat-spectrum, and Class II sources, estimate a stellar luminosity function for the Class II sample and search for a compatible IMF and age, and finally describe the spatial distribution of both the protostars and the pre-main sequence population in this cluster.
Table 1: Observational parameters, detection statistics and photometric results for each of the 6 ISOCAM rasters CE, CW, CS, D1, D2, D3. See Fig. 10 and text.
This work presents data from the two ISOCAM star formation surveys
LNORDH.SURVEY_1 and GOLOFSSO.D_SURMC. These were surveys within the
ISO central programme mapping selected parts of the major nearby star
formation regions in the two broad band filters LW2 (5-8.5
m) and
LW3 (12-18
m). Other results on young stellar populations based
on these surveys comprise the Chamaeleon I, II and III regions
(Persi et al. 2000; Nordh et al. 1996; Olofsson et al. 1998), the
Ophiuchi star formation region
(Bontemps et al. 2001), the R Corona Australis region (Olofsson et al. 1999), and the
L1551 Taurus region (Gålfalk et al. 2004), all observations performed basically
in the same way. Data reduction methods were generally the same for
all regions, using a combination of the CIA
(CAM Interactive Analysis) package and own
dedicated software. For overviews of survey results, see Nordh et al. (1998),
Kaas & Bontemps (2000), and Olofsson (2000).
In the Serpens Core region about 0.13 square degrees (deg2) were covered
at 6.7 and 14.3
m in 3 separate, but overlapping main rasters named
CE, CW and CS (see Fig. 10).
In addition, 3 smaller fields within CE (named D1, D2, and D3) were observed
at a higher sensitivity. CE covers the well known Serpens Cloud Core, CW is
a reference region to the west of the Core which is substantially opaque in
the optical but without appreciable 60
m IRAS emission (Zhang et al. 1988a),
and CS is a region directly to the south of the Cloud Core which has a peak
in the 60
m flux.
The rasters were always made along the right ascension, with about half
a frame (90
)
overlap in
and
overlap in
.
For the larger rasters the pixel field of view (PFOV) was set to the nominal
survey value of
except for the CE region in LW2, where a PFOV of
was selected because of the risk of otherwise saturating the detector.
Also in order to avoid saturation, the intrinsic integration time was set to
s except for field CW where the nominal survey value of
s was used. Each position in the sky was observed during
about 15 s. For the deeper imaging within CE the overlap was
in
and
,
and each position was observed during about 92 s.
The individual integration time was
s and a PFOV of
was used for better spatial resolution. See Table 1 for
an overview.
Each raster consists of a cube of frames which is reduced individually, and in total 9112 individual frames were analysed. The dark current was subtracted using the CAL-G dark from the ISOCAM calibration library and, if necessary, further improved by a second order dark correction using a FFT thresholding method (Starck et al. 1996a). Cosmic ray hits were detected and masked by the multiresolution median transform (MMT) method (Starck et al. 1996b). The transients in the time history of each pixel due to the slow response of the LW detector were treated with the IAS inversion method v.1.0 (Abergel et al. 1996a,b). Flat field images were constructed from the observations themselves. See Starck et al. (1999) for a general description of ISOCAM data processing.
Bright point sources, even well below the saturation level, produce strong memory effects which are not entirely taken out by the transient correction. Due to the large PFOV which undersamples the point spread function (PSF), also remnants of cosmic ray glitches may be mistaken for faint sources. By looking at the time history of the candidate source fluxes, however, it is easy to distinguish real sources from memory effects, glitches or noise. This is done for each individual sky coverage, the redundancy being 2-6. Both the source detection and the photometry was made with the interactive software developed by our team. See also previous papers on this survey (Bontemps et al. 2001; Olofsson et al. 1999; Nordh et al. 1996; Persi et al. 2000).
The fluxes of each verified source were measured by aperture photometry,
with nominal aperture radii 1.5 and 3 pixels, for the
and
PFOV, respectively, and aperture correction applied using the
empirical PSF. For each redundant observation (2-6 overlaps) the flux
is the median flux from the
readouts per sky position. The
sky level was estimated from the median image to reduce the noise.
Uncertainties are estimated both from the standard deviation around this
median (i.e. the temporal noise and also a measure of the efficiency of
the transient correction method) and from the
of the sky
background (i.e. the spatial noise). The quoted flux uncertainties are
these two contributions added in quadrature.
The photometric scatter between the overlaps is estimated and deviating measurements
are discarded. If a source is affected by the dead column (no 24 was
disconnected) or is hit by a serious glitch or memory effect in one of
the redundant overlaps, this one is skipped, and the remaining ones are used
to estimate the flux. If the redundancy is not sufficient (i.e. along raster
edges), then the fluxes are flagged if affected by the dead
column, detector edges, glitches, memory effects, close neighbours etc.
Source positions were calculated from that of the redundant images where
the source is closest to the centre, in order to diminish the effects of
field distortion. The source centre is taken to be the peak pixel, and
the default ISO pointing was used as a first source position value.
The ISO position was then compared to near-IR positions of known sources
in the literature (Giovannetti et al. 1998; Sogawa et al. 1997; Eiroa & Casali 1992), and ISO positions of bright
optical sources to the digital sky survey. Bulk offsets found for each
raster registration were then corrected. The maximum bulk offset found
was
,
and we estimated an average uncertainty of
in RA and Dec. When 2MASS became available we checked the positions of
61 sources in Table 2 which have 2MASS counterparts and are not
multiples unresolved by ISOCAM. The median deviation between ISOCAM and 2MASS
positions is
.
One star deviates by as much as
(ISO-356), and 5 more sources by more than
(these are ISO-29,
207, 272, 357 and 367).
The two broad band filters LW2 and LW3 have defined reference wavelengths
at 6.7 and 14.3
m, respectively. The fluxes in ADU/s are converted to
mJy through the relations 2.32 and 1.96 ADU/gain/s/mJy for the bands LW2 and
LW3, respectively (from in-orbit latest calibration by Blommaert et al. 2000). These
flux conversions are strictly valid only for sources with
,
however, and therefore a small colour correction must be applied
to the blue sources (cf. Sect. 3.2 for blue vs. red). This
correction is obtained by dividing the above conversion factors by 1.05 and
1.02 for LW2 and LW3, respectively, yielding the effective factors 2.21 and
1.92 ADU/gain/s/mJy for blue sources.
Conversion from flux density to magnitude is defined as
and
,
where
is given in Jy. The
%
responsivity decrease throughout orbit has not been corrected for.
A
region inside Serp-CE, the area which is
usually referred to as the Serpens Cloud Core and has been covered to
a smaller or larger extent by several studies in the near-IR
(Giovannetti et al. 1998; Kaas 1999a; Sogawa et al. 1997; Eiroa & Casali 1992), was mapped deeply in J (1.25
m),
H (1.65
m) and K (2.2
m) in August 1996, only 4 months
after the ISOCAM observations. See Fig. 10 for the location
of the different maps. Also, a region to the NW of the JHK field has
been mapped in the K band, see Fig. 4, but with a total
coadded integration time from only 30 s to 1 min.
These observations were made with the ARcetri Near Infrared CAmera
(Arnica) at the 2.56 m Nordic Optical Telescope, La Palma. See
Kaas (1999a) for details on this near-IR dataset.
A 1.3 mm dust continuum mosaic of the Serpens main cloud core was taken with
the IRAM 30-m telescope equipped with the MPIfR 37-channel bolometer array
MAMBO-I (Kreysa et al. 1998) during four night observing sessions in March 1998.
The passband of the MAMBO bolometer array has an equivalent width
70 GHz and is centered at
GHz.
The
mosaic consists of eleven individual on-the-fly maps
which were obtained in the dual-beam raster mode with a scanning velocity of
/s and a spatial sampling of
in elevation. In this mode,
the telescope is scanning continuously in azimuth along each mapped row while
the secondary mirror is wobbling in azimuth at frequency of 2 Hz. A wobbler
throw of
or
was used. The typical azimuthal size of
individual maps was
.
The size of the main beam was measured to be
(HPBW) on Uranus and other strong point-like sources such
as quasars. The pointing of the telescope was checked every
h
using the VLA position of the strong, compact Class 0 source FIRS1
(good to
- Curiel et al. 1993); it was found to be accurate to
better than
.
The zenith atmospheric optical depth, monitored
by "skydips'' every
h, was between
and
.
Calibration was achieved through on-the-fly mapping and on-off observations
of the primary calibrator Uranus (e.g., Griffin & Orton 1993, and references therein).
In addition, the Serpens secondary calibrator FIRS1, which has a 1.3 mm peak
flux density
Jy in an
beam was observed before and after
each map. The relative calibration was found to be good to within
by comparing the individual coverages of each field, while the overall
absolute calibration uncertainty is estimated to be
.
The dual-beam maps were reduced and combined with the IRAM software for bolometer-array data ("NIC''; cf. Broguière et al. 1995) which uses the EKH restoration algorithm (Emerson et al. 1979).
Table 1 gives an overview of the observational parameters and
the results of the point source photometry for each of the six rasters
named in Col. 1. Columns 2-4 give the centre position and size
of the raster fields. Columns 5-7 give the unit integration times,
the PFOV and the average number of readouts per sky position. Column 8
gives the total number of source detections. Columns 9 and 10 give the
number of sources for which photometry was obtained at 6.7 and 14.3
m, respectively. Column 11 gives the number of sources with flux
determinations in both of the photometric bands. Columns 12 and 13 give
the measured 1
photometric limits which are
about 4 and 6 times the read-out-noise
for the large and the deep fields, respectively. Practically all
sources detected at 14.3
m are also detected at 6.7
m, but there
are 15 cases of 14.3
m detections without 6.7
m counterparts.
On the average, only 30% of the 6.7
m detections are also detected
at 14.3
m, but this value is clearly larger for the CE field. The
sensitivity, which depends on the PFOV and
as well as the amount
of nebulosity and bright point sources, is lowered by memory effects
from bright sources in the CE field and by the presence of a nebula in
the CS field. For the deep fields (D1, D2, D3) the main limiting factor in
terms of sensitivity is the memory effect and the fact that the flat fields
are based on fewer frames.
The deep fields within the CE area are independently repeated observations
(observed within the same satellite orbit), and therefore permit a check
of the photometric repeatability for a number of sources. The median values
of the individual direct scatter between the measured fluxes were found to
be: about 30% for the 6.7
m band measured from 28 sources between 4 mJy
and 2 Jy, and about 15% for the 14.3
m band, measured from 14 sources
between 30 mJy and 5.7 Jy (note different pixel scale). This corresponds to
a median error of 0.13 dex in the
[14.3/6.7] colour index, which is in good
agreement with the scatter (of sources without mid-IR excesses) around the
value expected for normal photospheres (see Fig. 2) at a flux density
of 10 mJy in the 14.3
m band.
To estimate how many field stars to expect at a given sensitivity
within the observed fields, the stellar content in a cone along the
line-of-sight was integrated in steps of 0.02 kpc out to a distance
of 20 kpc. The Galaxy was represented by an exponential disk, a bulge,
a halo and a molecular ring, following Wainscoat et al. (1992).
Absolute magnitudes at 2.2
m (MK) and in the 12
m
IRAS band (
), local number densities and scale heights of
the different stellar populations, as well as their contribution to the
different components of the Galaxy were provided by Wainscoat et al. (1992) in their
model of the mid-IR point source sky.
Absolute magnitudes at 7
m,
,
are estimated by linear
interpolation between MK and
.
![]() |
Figure 1:
Histograms of sources at 6.7 |
| Open with DEXTER | |
The upper panels of Fig. 1 show the histograms of the 6.7
m
and 14.3
m sources in the CW field, which is free of nebulosity and
practically free of IR excess sources. The bin size of 0.2 in
corresponds to 0.5 mag. Inserted are the model counts of galactic
sources at 7 and 12
m, scaled to the CW field size. The expected source
number per bin is calculated assuming no cloud extinction (solid line), an
average extinction of 0.2 mag in the 6.7
m band (dotted line),
and
mag (dashed line), corresponding to roughly
and
,
respectively (cf. Sects. 4 and 5 about extinction).
For the CW field an average cloud extinction of
mag
is in agreement with the location of the majority of the sources in a
DENIS I-J/J-K' diagram, as well as an extinction map based on R star
counts (Cambrésy 1999).
Comparing the number of observed sources at 14.3
m with the model
expectation at 12
m indicates completeness at
6 mJy or
mag. The observations at 6.7
m are estimated
to be complete to
5 mJy or
mag.
The lower panels of Fig. 1 show the histograms for the total
sample. The boldface steps show the contribution of the mid-IR excess
sources. The dashed line represents the model expectation assuming an
average cloud extinction of about 10 mag of visual extinction,
i.e.
mag and
mag (cf.
Sects. 4 and 5).
Thus, the whole sample taken together, and allowing for a subtraction
of the mid-IR excess sources, indicates an overall completeness at
6 mJy for the 6.7
m band and at 8 mJy for the 14.3
m
band (i.e. at
mag and
mag).
![]() |
Figure 2:
The colour index
[14.3/6.7] defined as
|
| Open with DEXTER | |
For the 124 sources with fluxes in both bands we present a colour
magnitude diagram in Fig. 2. The colour index
[14.3/6.7],
defined as
,
is plotted against
.
This colour index can be converted to the commonly used
index of the Spectral Energy Distribution (SED):
![]() |
(1) |
The sources tend to separate into two distinct groups, with some few
intermediate objects. The "red'' sources (circles) are interpreted as
pre-main-sequence (PMS) stars surrounded by circumstellar dust. This
sample is not believed to be contaminated with galaxies. At the
completeness flux level of 8 mJy at 14.3
m the expected extragalactic
contamination is about half a source within our map coverage and at the
level of 3 mJy (the faintest source in our sample at 14.3
m) the
contamination is below two sources within the mapped region (Hony 2003).
No correction for extinction has been made on these numbers, so that they should be
considered as upper limits to the extragalactic contamination.
We have decided to set the division line between
mid-IR excess objects and "blue'' objects (triangles) at
[14.3/6.7] =
-0.2 or
(dotted line), which corresponds
to the classical border between Class II and Class III objects
(cf. Sect. 5).
Except for a few transition objects, the "blue'' group (triangles)
is mainly located at the colour index of normal photospheres, i.e.
[14.3/6.7] = -0.66 or
(dashed line). The
spread around this value indicates the increasing photometric uncertainty
with decreasing flux, although some of the scatter might be real. M giants
have intrinsic excesses in the colour index
[14.3/6.7] of less than 0.1,
while late M giants are expected to have excesses of up to
above
normal photospheres. Although late M giants are few, a number of M giants
are expected in the observed sample of field stars. Thus, the slight
displacement of this group of sources above the colour of normal
photospheres could be due to a combination of extinction and intrinsic
colours of M giants. The effect of extinction is small, however. A reddening
vector of size corresponding to AK = 3 is indicated in the figure.
(More about extinction in Sect. 4.)
This same dichotomy in colour was found also in the Chamaeleon dark clouds
(Nordh et al. 1996), in RCrA (Olofsson et al. 1999), and in
Ophiuchi (Bontemps et al. 2001).
According to the SED index,
,
the mid-IR excess
sources are Class II and Class I types of Young Stellar Objects (YSOs).
In Chamaeleon I about 40% of the mid-IR excess sources had been previously
classified as Classical T Tauri stars (CTTS), and in
Ophiuchi
50% were previously known as Class II and Class Is. In Serpens, very few
sources are optically visible and the IRAS data suffer badly from source
confusion. The known YSOs are thus a sample of sources classified from
near-IR excesses,
association with nebulosity, emission-line stars, ice features, clustering
properties, and variability (Hodapp et al. 1996; Giovannetti et al. 1998; Horrobin et al. 1997; Kaas 1999a; Sogawa et al. 1997; Eiroa & Casali 1992).
Previously known YSOs are not found in the "blue'' group, although
Class III sources, young stars with marginal or no IR excess, have their
locus there. A few objects in the transition phase between Class II and
Class III are evident in the "blue'' group. Class III sources without
IR excess cannot be distinguished from field stars purely on the basis of
broad band infrared photometry. They can, however, be efficiently identified
through X-ray observations.
![]() |
Figure 3:
The
|
| Open with DEXTER | |
Positions and photometry of the 53 Class I and Class II YSOs are listed
among other members of the Serpens Core cluster in Table 2.
The 71 "blue'' sources are listed in Table 3. Many of these are
field stars, but some are likely to be young cluster members of Class III
type. Figure 1 shows that the CW region contains as many as 20 (10)
sources detected at 6.7
m (14.3
m) above the expected field star
contribution according to the galactic model by Wainscoat et al. (1992). Because there
are only two IR excess sources in the CW field, of which one is very faint, these
are practically all belonging to the "blue'' sample.
Since the total region surveyed is about 3 times as large as the CW field,
perhaps more than 20 "blue'' sources from Table 3 could be
Class IIIs belonging to the cluster.
When it comes to detecting IR excesses, the J band usually limits the number
of sources in a J-H/H-K diagram because of its sensitivity to extinction.
For the ISOCAM observations the 14.3
m band is the less sensitive, unless
the sources are extremely red (see limits in Fig. 2). Using the
H-K/K-m6.7 diagram as in Olofsson et al. (1999), however, we should be able to
detect more IR excess objects. Figure 3 shows that practically all
sources with excesses in the colour index
[14.3/6.7] are also found to have
excesses in their
K - m6.7 index. Approximate intrinsic colours of
main-sequence, giant and supergiant stars, taken from the source table of
Wainscoat et al. (1992) and interpolated between 2.2 and 12
m, are given as boldface
curves (solid, dotted and dashed, respectively).
Sources with ISOCAM mid-IR excesses (circles) separate well from those
without mid-IR excesses (triangles). A reddening vector has been calculated
by fitting a line from origin through the 4 sources without mid-IR excesses.
The slope (1.23) is mainly constrained by the star CK2, which is believed
to be a background supergiant, see e.g. Casali & Eiroa (1996). On the basis of a
number of background stars in the J-H/H-K diagram, Kaas (1999a) found a
reddening law of the form
to fit the Serpens
data. Extrapolation of this law to 6.7
m would give a slope of 0.83 in
the
diagram, which is in disagreement with all the 4
sources without mid-IR excess. The
law
(Whittet 1988) gives an even shallower slope. By assuming, however, the
law to hold for H and K, and using
the empirical slope found in Fig. 3, the extinction in the 6.7
m band is estimated to be
.
This is in good agreement with the values 0.37, 0.35 and 0.47 found by Jiang et al. (2003)
from the ISOGAL survey, whose three values depend on the actual form of
the near-IR extinction curve applied.
![]() |
Figure 4:
Arnica K band mapping of the region to the NW of the JHK field.
ISOCAM sources are encircled and their identifications given.
Sources 159, 202, 216 and EC38 are YSOs with
[14.3/6.7] colour excess.
Sources SVS9 and 209 are without such an excess. The remaining sources
are not detected at 14.3 |
| Open with DEXTER | |
As shown in Kaas & Bontemps (2000) only about 50% of the IR excess sources which
display clear excesses in the single ISOCAM colour index
[14.3/6.7] show
up as IR excess objects in the J-H/H-K diagram. This was demonstrated
by plotting the same sources in the two diagrams, using a statistically
significant sample of several hundred sources in Serpens,
Ophiuchi,
Chamaeleon I, and RCrA. This result implies that a sole use of the J-H/H-K
diagram will severely underestimate the IR-excess population of YSOs in active
star formation regions. Bontemps et al. (2001) showed that in
Ophiuchi only
50% of the 123 Class II sources have near-IR excesses large enough to be
recognizable in the J-H/H-K diagram. Similarly we confirm here specifically
for Serpens that the mid-IR excess sources cluster along the reddening line
when plotted in a J-H/H-K diagram, and that only 50% would be recognized
as having IR excesses from JHK data alone.
The
H-K/K-m7 diagram is more efficient than the J-H/H-K diagram in
distinguishing between intrinsic circumstellar excess (circles) and reddening
(triangles). Thus, by sampling the SED a bit more into the mid-IR, the use
of two colour indices to select sources with intrinsic IR excesses becomes
substantially less prone to the influence from cloud extinction.
Figure 3 also shows that the mid-IR excesses apparent from the
[14.3/6.7] index, always appear already at 6.7
m, but only in half
of the cases at 2.2
m.
In addition to the 53 IR excess sources obtained from Fig. 2,
another eight sources were found to have IR excess from the
H-K/K-m7
diagram, i.e. displaced by more than 1
to the right of the reddening
band (dotted line). This means we find 25% more IR excess sources within
the centre region than by using the
[14.3/6.7] index alone.
Class II sources are most likely Classical T Tauri stars (CTTS), but we can
not exclude that some of them are weak-lined T Tauri stars (WTTS). Among
the Class II sources detected with ISOCAM in Chamaeleon I about 1/3 had been
previously classified as WTTS (Nordh et al. 1996).
For WTTS one could attribute the presence of mid-IR excess but a lack of
near-IR excess to an inner hole in the circumstellar disk (Moneti et al. 1999).
CTTS, on the other hand, are believed to have inner disks, since they show
strong H
emission, which is commonly interpreted as a signature of
the accretion process onto the surface of the object, but could also arise
in stellar winds. Optical information is scarce in the Serpens Cloud Core
because of the large cloud extinction, and we do not know what fraction of
the Class IIs are strong H
emitters.
It is well known from studies of CTTS locations in the J-H/H-K diagram
(Lada & Adams 1992; Meyer et al. 1997), that many CTTS lack detectable near-IR excesses; about
40% in Taurus-Auriga according to Strom et al. (1993).
For typical CTTS the near-IR wavelength region is strongly dominated by the
photospheric emission, and rather large amounts of dust hot enough to produce
a strong excess at 2
m are therefore needed in order to distinguish
intrinsic IR excess from the effects of scattering and extinction in the
J-H/H-K diagram. In a region such as the Serpens Cloud Core, where 7 of
the Class IIs in question here were originally proposed to be YSOs due to
their association with nebulosity (Eiroa & Casali 1992), it is likely that
scattered light in the J and H bands adds to the lack of detectable
near-IR excesses as it gives a bluer H-K colour index.
From an ISOCAM sample of CTTS with mid-IR excesses in Chamaeleon I,
Comerón et al. (2000) found evidence for the presence of near-IR excesses to be
correlated with luminosity, suggesting an incapability of objects with very
low temperatures and luminosities (young brown dwarfs and very low mass CTTS)
to raise the temperature needed at the inner part of the circumstellar disk
to produce a detectable excess at 2.2
m, in agreement with model
predictions (Meyer et al. 1997).
The majority of the Serpens sources are substantially more luminous. As pointed
out by Hillenbrand et al. (1998), the larger the stellar radius (i.e. the younger the star
is), the more difficult it is to separate near-IR excesses from the stellar
flux. This could perhaps be part of the explanation for the youngest sources
(e.g. two flat-spectrum sources without near-IR excess). But we found all the
Class I sources to possess near-IR excesses, such that the role of larger
radii in these cases seems to be well compensated for, probably by their
larger disk accretion rates.
A statistical interpretation based on broad band photometry is likely
over-simplified, however, and there are many properties intrinsic to the
star-disk system (such as disk inclination angle, disk accretion rate,
stellar mass and radius) which contribute to the complexity of the
individual YSOs. From the results presented here for Serpens, in
Bontemps et al. (2001) for
Ophiuchi, and in Kaas & Bontemps (2000) for the ISOCAM star
formation surveys in general, it is evident that one should be careful in
estimating disk frequencies among YSOs based on near-IR excesses only,
see also Haisch et al. (2001). Since our study samples only IR excess objects, we
cannot say anything about the disk fraction among YSOs in Serpens.
![]() |
Figure 5:
The spectral index
|
| Open with DEXTER | |
We have combined the photometry from ISOCAM with the available K band
photometry from 1996
(Kaas 1999a) and calculated the two SED indices:
and
,
which are plotted against each other in
Fig. 5 for the 39 mid-IR excess sources and the 6 sources
without mid-IR excesses. The index
is close to
the index originally used to define the three Classes I-III from
the shape of their SED between 2.2 and 10 (or 25)
m by
Lada & Wilking (1984); Lada (1987).
Figure 5 indicates the loci of these classes in addition to
a transitional class referred to as "flat spectrum" sources.
According to the updated IR spectral classification scheme (Greene et al. 1994; André & Montmerle 1994)
we tentatively define YSOs with
as Class I
sources, those with
as flat-spectrum
sources, and objects with
as Class II
sources.
There is a marginal hint of a gap in the distribution of sources along
the
[14.3/6.7] = -0.2 axis at
,
which
was seen also in the
Ophiuchi sample (Bontemps et al. 2001), though at
0.5.
It is apparent that we cannot distinguish between Class III sources and
field stars. (The transition sources in the "blue'' group (see
Fig. 2) with some mid-IR excesses are all located outside the
field for which we have K-band observations.)
IR excess sources without detection at 14.3
m (see Sect. 4.2) can be
classified from the approximately linear relation between
and
found in
Fig. 5. In this case Class Is are those which have
,
corresponding to
K-m7 > 4.8, Class IIs
are those which have
,
corresponding to
K-m7 < 3.2, and flat-spectrum sources are those in between. Thus, the
total number of sources in each category is larger than apparent from
Fig. 5. From Fig. 3 we have 1 more Class I, 2 more
flat-spectrum sources, and 5 more Class IIs. Three sources (260, 277 and 308)
have only K and 6.7
m detections, but their very red colours strongly
suggest membership in the Class I category.
The number of Class I sources (19) is thus about equal to the number of
Class II sources (18) in the central part of the Serpens cluster. This is
very unusual since Class II sources
outnumber Class I sources by typically 10 to 1 in star formation regions.
If we include the 13 "flat spectrum" sources in the Class II group, the
Class I/Class II number ratio is still as high as 19/31. This is
exceptional, also compared to the results obtained from ISOCAM surveys in
other regions; in Chamaeleon I this number ratio is 5/42 (Kaas 1999b)
and in
Ophiuchi: 16/123 (Bontemps et al. 2001). Such a large population of
Class I sources indicates a recent burst of star formation in this region
and would be in line with the rich collection of Class 0 objects found in
this cluster by Casali et al. (1993) and Hurt & Barsony (1996).
While a spectral index between two fixed wavelengths, such as 2.2 and 14.3
m, is practical and provides a preliminary classification for a large
number of sources, a truly reddening-independent classification is obtainable
only when complete SEDs are available over the
2 to 100
m range
(or to 1.3 mm if Class 0 sources are involved). In the following we discuss
the possibility that sources defined as Class Is from the
index could be heavily extinguished Class II or
flat-spectrum sources.
The source CK2 (probably a background supergiant) is seen through more than
50 mag of visual extinction (Kaas 1999a), and indicates
an empirical slope (=1.6) of the extinction law in Fig. 5,
as do five other sources without mid-IR excesses. This reddening
line translates to a slope of 0.92 in the
K-m7/K-m14 diagram,
which gives the relation
= 0.88
in terms of magnitudes
,
by using the relation
A7 = 0.41 AK obtained in Sect. 4.
It is remarkable that the group of mid-IR excess sources are lined up along
the same slope as the one outlined by the reddened field stars. In this
sense, some of the sources classified as Class I objects on the basis of
Fig. 5 could be interpreted as highly extinguished Class II
objects, either deeply embedded in the cloud or seen edge-on.
Flat-spectrum sources and Class IIs are generally expected to be optically
visible objects. In Serpens, however, only one (ISO-Ser-159) of the 13
flat-spectrum sources and only three of the 18 Class IIs are optically
visible. This shows the extreme degree of embeddedness, and is in agreement
with the C18O map of White et al. (1995), which suggests that the visual cloud
extinction is larger than 30 mag everywhere in the NW-SE ridge and may
reach values as high as
in some places.
The fact that the slopes are so similar suggests that Class Is are either
merely more embedded Class IIs, or that the extinction behaves roughly in
the same way for Class I envelopes as for the cloud in general at these
wavelengths. This would be in line with Padgett et al. (1999) who observed three
Class I SED YSOs with HST/NICMOS and found edge-on disks in all three cases.
As shown in Fig. 2 the
index is rather
insensitive to extinction.
As many as 15 YSOs in our sample have
,
but
,
among them the well known DEOS. For some of
these we have more spectral information than the three flux points at 2.2,
6.7 and 14.3
m. The two sources HB1 and EC129 are relatively isolated
YSOs both in the near-IR and mid-IR images and should not suffer so much
from the source confusion that sets a limit to the usefulness of IRAS data
for the other sources. We use HIRES IRAS fluxes and upper limits from
Hurt & Barsony (1996) and extend our mid-IR SEDs to longer wavelengths.
Figure 6 shows that both HB1 and EC129 (HB2) have rising spectra
beyond a clear dip in the SED at
14
m. These sources have clearly
Class I SEDs, but the dip at
14
m will produce a blue
index.
![]() |
Figure 6:
SEDs of HB1 and EC129. The flux points at 25, 60 and 100 |
| Open with DEXTER | |
Hurt & Barsony (1996) divided the flux from their HIRES map of IRAS 18272+0114
between the three sources DEOS, EC53 and S68N, while ISOCAM resolves six
mid-IR excess sources (cf. Fig. 11), of which only EC37 has
.
It is possible that a broad silicate absorption feature and/or the presence
of H2O and CO2 ices in the 14.3
m band (de Graauw et al. 1996; Whittet et al. 1996) may
cause absorption effects that correspond in magnitude to the observed dips
in the SEDs at
14
m, noting that the effect is there for the
most deeply embedded sources. Recently, ISOCAM-CVF spectroscopy of 42
Class I and Class II YSOs in Serpens,
Ophiuchi, Chamaeleon and RCrA
by Alexander et al. (2003) reveals a number of absorption features from 5 to 18
m. They find that the majority of Class I sources fall in their
category a, having deep absorption features of ices and silicates,
and conclude that in the cases of large extinction the continuum spectral
index between 2 and 14
m provides a truer value of the shape of the
underlying continuum than the observed mid-IR spectrum.
For the sub-sample of 20 sources that were studied by Alexander et al. (2003) in
Serpens we found: four Class Is, six flat-spectrum sources, four Class II
sources, one "blue'' source, and we did not detect five of their sources.
All four Class Is, three flat-spectrum sources, and one Class II fall in
their group a, and two flat-spectrum sources and three Class IIs in
their category b (only SVS2 is of type c). This comparison shows
overall good agreement, and indicates that we have not overestimated the
number of Class Is in our study.
Also, the presence of shocked molecular H2 line emission in the 6.7
m band (e.g., Larsson et al. 2002; Cabrit et al. 1998) included in the measured flux of some
of the youngest sources could contribute to give a bluer
index than expected from a dust continuum.
Recent 2-D models of Class I source geometries by Whitney et al. (2003) which include
flared disk and bipolar cavity produce mid-IR SEDs with very broad dips around
10
m, and overall much bluer mid-IR colours than produced by simple 1D
or simplified 2-D models.
![]() |
Figure 7:
The average flux at 6.7 and 14.3 |
| Open with DEXTER | |
Based on the previous discussion we trust that the
index gives a more reliable measure of the SED than the
index. We have also looked at the mid-IR fluxes of Class Is versus Class IIs.
If all the 15 YSOs with
and
were reddened
Class II sources, one would expect them to be on the average fainter than
(or at most as bright as) the YSOs with
.
We note, however, that there is a slight tendency that sources with large
indices also are, on the average, the brightest
ones in the mid-infrared.
Figure 7 shows the average flux at 6.7 and 14.3
m versus
,
with a reddening vector of AK = 3 mag
inserted. The filled circles in the figure mark the 15 sources that have
and
.
Excluding the flat-spectrum sources, the median fluxes are 0.18 and 0.029 Jy for 15 Class Is and 27 Class IIs (including all those from
Table 6 that have mid-IR fluxes), respectively. For comparison,
the median mid-IR fluxes of 16 Class Is and 76 Class IIs in
Ophiuchi
are 1.17 and 0.095 Jy, respectively (Bontemps et al. 2001). In Chamaeleon I for 5
Class Is and 42 Class IIs these numbers are 0.28 and 0.077 Jy,
respectively. While the statistics is low for the Chamaeleon I Class I sources,
there is an indication of luminosity evolution from the Class I to the
Class II phase, the case being strongest for
Ophiuchi. We conclude that
on the basis of this statistical luminosity argument, there seems to be an
intrinsic difference between the Class I and the Class II populations.
Noting that Class Is are on the average more luminous in the mid-IR than Class IIs (cf. Bontemps et al. 2001), we caution that it is not entirely excluded that the large number fraction of Class I sources in Serpens could be a direct effect of a lower sensitivity because of a larger distance. There are about 80 faint YSO candidates in the Serpens Cloud Core below the sensitivity limit of ISOCAM (Kaas 1999a).
Although the exact Class I/Class II number ratio might become subject to
modification when future observations at high spatial resolution and
sensitivity towards longer wavelengths are available (SIRTF-Spitzer at 24
m and FIRST-Herschel at 90-250
m), we believe that the main
conclusion of an unusually large fraction of Class I sources in the Serpens
Cloud Core will be maintained.
Based on the discussion in the previous paragraph, we have arrived at a
sample of 20 Class I SED sources which are listed in Table 4 with
the two SED indices
and
.
These are all protostar candidates. Although Class 0 sources normally
are not expected to be detectable at shorter wavelengths than about
25
m, we detect two Class I sources, ISO-241 and ISO-308, within the
positional uncertainties of S68N and SMM4, respectively
.
Motte & André (2001) found that about 60% of the Class I sources in Taurus-Auriga
are "true protostars'', using the criterion that the envelope mass to
stellar mass fraction is
0.1. A similar method has been applied to the
Serpens data. But first we exclude 3 sources in order to account for the
possible confusion with Class 0 sources (in the case of EC41) or contribution
of Class 0 sources (in the cases: ISO-241, ISO-308) in the sample of 19
Class Is in the region mapped by IRAM. The fraction of bona-fide protostars
in the Serpens Core is then estimated to be 9 out of 16 Class Is or 56%, with
an uncertainty of
10% because of source confusion problems with the
strong clustering.
Table 4:
The 20 Class I sources.
and FWHM refers to
measured variability 1995-1996 (Kaas 1999a) and extendedness in
the K-band, respectively. K-band magnitudes from 1996 are found in
Table 2.
Extended, elongated and polarized near-IR emission is predicted by models of
infalling envelopes which have developed cavities owing to bipolar outflows,
where near-IR radiation from the central object may escape and scatter off
dust in the cavity and the outer envelope, see e.g. Whitney et al. (1997). Park & Kenyon (2002)
find that 70% of the bona-fide protostars in Taurus are extended in the
near-IR, and that less than 10% of the sources that are
extended in the near-IR show no extension in mm continuum. Our near-IR data
has a spatial resolution about 10 times better than the IRAM map, and we have
included in Table 4 the full width at half maximum (FWHM) of a
Gaussian fit to the source profiles in the K band images. The median FWHM
of 160 isolated and relatively bright sources over the field is
.
Sources with a FWHM greater than
,
i.e. above
3
,
are here defined as extended in the K-band. For the Class I sources
this concerns 8 of 19 sources or 42%, highly coinciding with continuum
sources except for ISO-331 and ISO-260. There are no extended sources in the
flat-spectrum and Class II samples.
Substantial K-band variability was found in 8 of the above Class I sources,
5 of the flat-spectrum sources and 5 of the Class II sources (Kaas 1999a).
The brightness variations of the Class I sources are given in Table 4
as
.
The median value of the amplitude is
mag,
larger than the variations found for Class Is in Taurus (Park & Kenyon 2002).
Table 5:
The 13 flat-spectrum sources.
and FWHM refers to
measured variability 1995-1996 (Kaas 1999a) and extendedness in
the K-band, respectively. K-band magnitudes from 1996 are found in
Table 2.
The flat-spectrum sources are believed to be in a transition phase between the Class I and the Class II stage, but a few of these might be found to be true protostars. We have listed them in Table 5 with SED indices, K-band FWHM and variability amplitude. Both SVS2 and SVS20 have centrosymmetric polarization patterns, indicating that evacuated bipolar cavities surround them, and both are double sources (Huard et al. 1997). Among the flat-spectrum sources ISO-159, EC129, SVS20, and ISO-237 (i.e. 30%) are detected as mm continuum sources in our IRAM map.
Table 6:
The 43 ISOCAM YSOs found to be Class II sources or candidates.
A hyphen for the SED indices means no detection at 14
m. AK is
the derived extinction in the K-band, and
is the stellar
luminosity estimated as explained in Sect. 6.
is the
amplitude of the K-band variability 1995-1996 (Kaas 1999a). None of
the sources for which Arnica K images were available was found to be
extended in K.
Based on the ISOCAM YSO sample found in Table 2 we have used a
combination of criteria to arrive at a tentative sample of Class II sources
in Serpens. These are listed in Table 6 with SED indices, whenever
available, and additional criteria used to argue for a Class II status. Since
our K imaging from 1996 only covers about 10% of the ISOCAM survey, we
have also used published K band photometry whenever available to calculate
the SED indices.
Also, we have assumed that if the source shows strong mid-IR excess and is
optically visible, it is more likely to be a Class II than a flat-spectrum
or Class I type of YSO. As a supporting argument for Class II designation
we have found for a few mid-IR excess sources without JHK data, strong
H
in emission (to be published in a future paper). When the 2MASS
All-Sky Data Release became available while we were finalizing our
investigation,
we used the near-IR photometry from their point source catalogue for the
Class II source candidates where such data was lacking, and found spectral
indices in agreement with our above reasoning.
The pre-main sequence population also includes the Class III type of YSOs, objects which show no IR signatures of an optically thick disk. Since the basic criterion for selecting YSOs in our study is IR excess, we do not sample these sources. With the existing photometric data alone we cannot distinguish Class IIIs from field stars, except for a few objects in the transition zone between the Class II and Class III phases. The clear gap between the two groups formed in the ISOCAM colour-magnitude diagram in Fig. 2 demonstrates that there are few objects undergoing this transition, i.e. that the transition must be rapid. This is evident in all the star formation regions surveyed by ISOCAM. In Serpens at least five sources from Table 3 belong to this transition group, cf. Fig. 2, and we list them as candidate Class IIIs in Table 7. None of these are located in the central Cloud Core region covered by Arnica deep near-IR imaging.
Only about 10% of the Serpens area surveyed by ISOCAM was covered by deep
JHK photometry. The total sample is therefore not as homogeneous as
our surveys in
Ophiuchi (Bontemps et al. 2001), Chamaeleon (Persi et al. 2000) and
RCrA (Olofsson et al. 1999). Also, since Serpens is at a larger distance the overall
sensitivity is lower, and source confusion is worse, especially in the very
clustered active centre. With our deep RIJHK photometric
coverage over the whole ISOCAM survey, which will be published in a future
paper, we expect to extend the population of IR excess
sources, and reveal YSOs which are below the ISO sensitivity. With near-IR
photometry for the whole sample we can also improve the luminosity
estimate of the Class II sources, by dereddening the J-band fluxes,
analogously to what was done for
Ophiuchi (Bontemps et al. 2001).
At the moment we estimate the luminosities from the mid-IR 6.7
m band
only, because this is the most homogeneous measurement we have. The 6.7
m luminosity function is shown in Fig. 8 for the Class I
and flat-spectrum sources (lower) and Class II sources (upper).
Protostars are expected to radiate most of their luminosity at longer
wavelengths. To derive their bolometric luminosities we need to integrate
the observed SEDs. As shown in Sect. 8, however, the four
IRAS sources found in the CE region correspond each to a number of protostars.
For reasons of source confusion we have not attempted to make calorimetric
luminosity estimates of the Class Is in Serpens, as was done for the
Class I sample in
Ophiuchi, see Bontemps et al. (2001) who
found that the typical fraction of the luminosity radiated between 6.7
and 14.3
m for a Class I source is
.
As shown in Fig. 8 the protostars span a range in mid-IR
luminosities about equal to that of the Class IIs. It is clear that the
protostars are on the average more luminous at 6.7
m than the
Class IIs. This is expected as a large fraction of the luminosity of a
protostar is the accretion luminosity. The accretion can be partly
continuous and partly happen in bursts, so that the luminosity of a
protostar is far from being a simple function of its age and mass.
Class II sources are found to radiate the bulk of their flux in the
near-IR. The 6.7
m band is expected to be dominated by disk emission,
e.g. for a simple black-body at T = 3700 K only about 8% of the luminosity
is radiated in this band (Bontemps et al. 2001). Thus we can relate the mid-IR flux
to the total stellar
luminosity by assuming that what we see is dust emission from a passive
reprocessing circumstellar disk. For most Class II sources any contribution
to the luminosity from an active accretion disk is assumed to be negligible.
This is supported by measurements of the disk accretion rates of CTTS in
Taurus, which are found to have a median value of only
yr-1 (e.g., Gullbring et al. 1998). If the dust in the disk is distributed
roughly as in the ideal case of an infinite, spatially flat disk, 25% of
the central source luminosity is absorbed and reradiated by the dust
(Adams & Shu 1986). If the disk is flared, the percentage increases, and if it has
an inner hole, it decreases. Furthermore, the disk inclination angle i (to
the line of sight) determines what fraction of the disk luminosity we observe.
In addition, we have to correct for cloud extinction. Since many of our
Class II sources are not detected at 14.3
m we select to use the
6.7
m flux only.
![]() |
Figure 8:
The 6.7 |
| Open with DEXTER | |
Olofsson et al. (1999) calibrated an empirical relation between the observed
6.7
m flux and the stellar luminosity by selecting sources with known
spectral class and very small extinction in RCrA and Chamaeleon I.
Correcting this relation to the larger distance of Serpens we get here
that
.
Before we
can apply this relation, however, we have to correct F6.7 for cloud
extinction.
For the 21 Class IIs which have Arnica JHK photometry, we assume an intrinsic
colour of
(J-H)0 = 0.85, which is a median value with small dispersion
found for CTTS (Meyer et al. 1997; Strom et al. 1993), and estimate the extinction in the
K-band,
,
applying the
extinction law for the near-IR found for Serpens (Kaas 1999a). Sources
without J-band photometry are either not detected in J - probably owing
to extinction - or they are located outside the area observed in the near-IR.
In the first case (ISO-Ser-226, 269, 279) we interpolate extinction values
of their neighbouring Class II sources, and in the second case we use the
recently available 2MASS PSC and a dereddening as above. We do not transform
from 2MASS
to Arnica K, since the difference is less than or about
equal to the estimated errors in the photometry (0.01-0.02 mag).
All extinction values are listed in Table 6 expressed as AK,
but only approximate values are given for ISO-Ser-226, 269 and 279, since
it cannot be known at which depth in the cloud these objects reside. In
Sect. 4 we found the relation
A6.7 = 0.41 AK, which is used
to correct the 6.7
m flux. The derived stellar luminosity
for each Class II source is also listed in Table 6. The uncertainty
in the luminosity estimate is a function of the uncertainties in: 1) the
extinction estimate; 2) the distance; 3) the
vs. F6.7 relation
itself, of which the last two
will be systematic errors for the whole sample. Comparison with previous
luminosity estimates by Eiroa & Casali (1992), but scaled to the distance we use,
shows that for the 13 objects that overlap in these two samples, there is
a large scatter; the fraction
L/LEC92 varies from 0.5 to 3.7 but the
median value is 1.1.
The completeness estimate we found in Sect. 3.1 for detections in
the 6.7
m band is 6 mJy. Because of the variable extinction this cannot
be directly translated to a completeness for Class II sources in terms
of stellar luminosities. We have used the average measured extinction of
AK = 1.0 for our Class II sample and calculated that the completeness
limit is at
.
Table 7: Five candidate Class III sources from Table 3. These are probably in the transition phase between Class II and III having some remaining IR excess. K-band magnitudes for two sources are obtained from Kaas et al. (1995).
Eiroa & Casali (1992) first estimated a luminosity function (LF) for the young cluster
in the Serpens Cloud Core, including their 51 identified cluster members. The
stellar luminosities were obtained from a trapezoidal integration over the
detected wavelengths, extrapolated to longer wavelengths and
extinction-corrected. This LF showed a pronounced peak around 1
and a
turnover below 0.2
.
Giovannetti et al. (1998) evaluated synthetic K-band
luminosity functions (KLFs) and found a best fit to their observed KLF with
two bursts of star formation, one 0.1 Myrs ago and the other around 3 Myrs ago,
and an underlying Miller & Scalo IMF. This was partly based on their finding
of a turnover in the KLF above K = 14 mag. A later study expanded the number
of Serpens members and found no evidence for a turnover of the KLF down to a
limit of K = 16 mag (Kaas 1999a). The weakness of KLFs is that differential
extinction is not taken into account, and for Serpens this is especially
important as values as high as
mag have been observed for background
stars, and
mag is expected for the densest regions of the NW-SE
ridge (White et al. 1995).
By selecting sources in the Class II phase only, we here constrain the age
spread somewhat (Bontemps et al. 2001). This phase is thought to last of the order
of a few Myr. This means that Class IIs can have a similar age spread, but we
cannot rule out that the Class IIs once formed in a burst like we see now
for the protostars (cf. Sect. 8). We have here made the simple
assumption of coeval star formation. In Fig. 9 we show our
observed LF for the sample of 43 Class II sources (shaded histograms).
The bin width of the histogram is
,
based on a factor of
two uncertainty in the luminosity estimate, and the histogram has been shifted
and the bin size slightly varied to check that the presented distribution
remains stable. The observed LF shows a pronounced peak at
,
but this corresponds roughly to the completeness limit we have
estimated for this sample (dotted vertical line). The error bars are the
statistical counting errors (
). The many luminous objects of around
found by Eiroa & Casali (1992) have disappeared as the sample has been
restricted to Class II sources.
![]() |
Figure 9:
Synthetic LFs were calculated for 4 different ages of a coeval
population on the basis of pre-main sequence tracks of D'Antona & Mazzitelli (1998) and 3
different underlying IMFs. The number of sources per bin is plotted vs.
|
| Open with DEXTER | |
We have assumed coeval populations and three different underlying IMFs:
the Salpeter IMF (Salpeter 1955), the Kroupa et al. three-segment
power-law IMF (Kroupa et al. 1993), and the Scalo three-segment power-law IMF
(Scalo 1998), hereafter S55, KTG93 and S98, respectively. With the IMF in
the form:
,
the
Salpeter IMF has one single index:
,
originally determined
for the mass interval 0.4 to 10
but in Fig. 9
extrapolated to lower masses for reference. Both the KTG93 and S98 IMFs
have three different values of
for three (differently divided)
segments. Bontemps et al. (2001) found for a large sample of Class II objects in
Ophiuchi that the high mass end of the mass function was well fitted
with the index
.
Also, they found that the IMF starts to flatten at
and stays "flat'' down to
with a power-law index
.
These best fits of the two free parameters
and
result in a mass function close to both the KTG93 and S98
IMFs for
Ophiuchi.
![]() |
Figure 10:
Spatial distribution of the ISOCAM sources in the Serpens Cloud.
Sources with mid-IR excesses (filled circles) are seen to cluster
strongly in the Cloud Core (field CE), while the CW field contains
almost exclusively sources without mid-IR excesses (open circles).
Indicated are also sources with 6.7 |
| Open with DEXTER | |
On the basis of the pre-main sequence evolutionary models of D'Antona & Mazzitelli (1998,1994), with the 1998 upgrade for low mass stars, we have computed synthetic LFs for each IMF and for the four different ages: 0.5, 1, 2 and 3 Myr of a coeval cluster. Each window in Fig. 9 shows the result for one age, and the computed LFs are overplotted on the observed LF. The peak in the LF which wanders towards lower luminosities with increasing age arises because of the deuterium burning phase (Zinnecker et al. 1993). Deuterium burning acts like a thermostat and hampers somewhat the contraction down the Hayashi track, causing a build-up of sources in a given luminosity bin for the case of coeval star formation. The peak in the observed LF, however, is approximately at the completeness limit of the sample, and we cannot put too much confidence in it. Nevertheless, it is obvious from the figure that the observed LF excludes ages of less than about 1 Myr for this Class II population for any of three underlying IMFs, which is in agreement with current understanding of YSO evolution. It is not possible to distinguish between the S98 IMF (solid line) and the KTG93 IMF (dashed), but both of them are plausible for a coeval population with an age of about 2 Myr, all the way down to the estimated completeness limit. Also the Salpeter IMF (dashed-dotted line) is in agreement with the observed LF for ages of 2-3 Myr at the high luminosity end. Its extrapolation to lower masses is given in the plots just for reference.
Note, however, that if star formation proceeds in a more continuous fashion, the structures in the model LFs will smooth out. We have checked the model LFs for the case of continuous star formation over several intervals from 0.5 to 3 Myrs. Although the statistics in the observed LF is poor, it seems we can exclude the combination of the above tested IMFs and continuous SF over periods of less than 2 Myrs. We also tested the case of a single star formation burst taking place 2 Myr ago but having various durations from 0.2 to 1.0 Myr. The peak in the observed LF is not secure enough to discriminate between the various burst durations. For the tested IMFs and SF histories, all we can conclude is that an age of less than 2 Myr for the Class II population seems implausible.
Corrections for binarity have not been applied, but such a correction
would increase the populations in the lowest luminosity bins. We conclude
that with the currently obtained LF the Class II mass function in Serpens is
similar to the one in
Ophiuchi (Bontemps et al. 2001), even though flat-spectrum
sources were included in the
Ophiuchi sample. We note that the typical
stellar mass found for the Serpens Class II sample (i.e. the median) is 0.17
,
the same as in
Ophiuchi (Bontemps et al. 2001). The total mass of
the Class II sample in Serpens is
.
We have also used the Baraffe et al. (1998) evolutionary tracks and calculated synthetic LFs with the same underlying IMFs as above and for the ages: 1, 2, 3, and 4 Myr. This model gives basically the same result as that of D'Antona & Mazzitelli (1998) for the degree of confidence we can put in our observed LF, taking the large error bars in the histogram into account.
Adopting the above deduced age of 2 Myr for the Serpens Class II
population, our study is estimated to be complete to about
,
but to reach down to
.
Taking
as the
border between low mass stars and brown dwarfs, we find 9 sub-stellar size
objects in the Serpens Class II sample (those with
in Table 6). These are young brown dwarfs
(BDs) apparently going through a Class II phase just like low mass
stars. They all have IR excesses with no apparent deviations from other
Class IIs in any aspect, which is consistent with the idea that they formed
in the same way as low-mass stars do. Our sample of BDs is not complete,
however, and we cannot discuss the frequency of occurrence of disks among
BDs or set strong constraints on BD formation models.
Based on the age estimate above, we find that
21% of the Class II sample studied is made up of free-floating
brown dwarfs. This is similar to the percentage found in
Ophiuchi
(Bontemps et al. 2001). The percentage in terms of mass is, however, only about
3% of the total mass for the whole Class II sample.
The spatial distribution of the ISOCAM sources is shown in Fig. 10
together with the location of the three main rasters CE, CW and CS. The filled
circles indicate sources with mid-IR excesses (cf. Table 2), the
open circles are the sources without mid-IR excesses (cf. Table 3),
the plus signs are sources with 6.7
m fluxes only, and crosses sources
with 14.3
m fluxes only. The small box outlines the
field for which deep JHK imaging is obtained. The overall spatial
distribution of the mid-IR excess YSOs shows a very clear concentration along
a SE-NW oriented ridge within the CE field, mainly coinciding with what is
known as the Serpens Cloud Core. In the CW field there is practically no sign
of activity, while the distribution of IR-excess YSOs in the CS field is quite
scattered. The majority of the mid-IR excess sources seem to be distributed
along a curved filament pointing towards a centre of curvature around 18:29:10,
+01:05:00 (J2000). Nothing particular was found at this location searching
SIMBAD, however, and whether star formation along this arc may be externally
triggered remains speculative. The IRAS Point Source Catalogue contains six
sources in the area surveyed by ISOCAM (cf. Appendix A for details).
![]() |
Figure 11:
Dust continuum mosaic (contours and greyscale) of the Serpens main
core taken at 1.3 mm with the IRAM 30 m telescope and the MPIfR 37-channel
bolometer array (MAMBO). Contour levels: 50. to 200 by 50, 300 to 1000.
by 100. mJy/11
|
| Open with DEXTER | |
The concentration of young sources found along the NW-SE ridge, corresponds
well to the pronounced density enhancement seen in the IRAM 1300
m map
in Fig. 11. It is evident that the Class I and the flat-spectrum
sources are spatially more confined to the NW-SE ridge than the Class II
sources, which have a more scattered distribution. In particular, the
protostars seem to form a set of sub-clusters lined up along the ridge.
These sub-clusters are in good positional agreement with the kinematically
separated N2H+ cores A, B, C, D found by Testi et al. (2000), especially with
B, C, and D. The SVS4 sub-cluster lies between cores A and B, however, and is
also displaced to the west of the SMM4 mm continuum peak.
![]() |
Figure 12:
A K band image of the Serpens Cloud Core (
|
| Open with DEXTER | |
The spatial distribution of all the classes of YSOs within the central
of the Cloud Core can be seen overlaid on a K band image
in Fig. 12. To quantify the scale of sub-clustering of
the two populations: protostar candidates (Class I and flat-spectrum
sources) and Class II sources, we show for each population the distribution
of separations between the sources.
Figure 13 shows the result as the number of pairs vs. separation.
The bin size was chosen to be 6 times the minimum separation. The difference
between the two populations is clear. The protostar candidates (circles) have
a minimum scale of clustering of about 0.12 pc (
), a secondary
peak at 0.36 pc, and practically no scattered distribution, while the
Class II sources have a minimum clustering scale of about 0.25 pc, a secondary
peak at 0.59 pc and a much more distributed population, in agreement with the
maps. The clustering scale of 0.12 pc for the protostars agrees well with the
range of radii of the N2H+ cores: 0.055 to 0.115 pc (Olmi & Testi 2002),
and the second peak at about 0.4 pc reflects well the size scale of the most
active region in the Serpens Core.
The correspondence between the high density gas and the compactness of the
protostar clusters indicates that these sources are found close to their
birth place. Assuming a typical velocity dispersion in the range from 0.1
to 1 km s-1, YSOs younger than 105 yrs can be expected to have
moved at most 0.1 pc from their birth place. The typical ages of Class I
sources are estimated to be of this order in other regions such as
Ophiuchi (Greene et al. 1994) and Taurus (Kenyon et al. 1990). Our results indicate that
the protostar candidates in each cluster must have formed from the same
core at about the same time, which may put constraints on models of cloud
fragmentation and core formation within clumps. Each sub-cluster contains
between 6 and 12 protostar candidates, and this is just a lower limit because
of the spatial resolution of ISOCAM. Adopting the Serpens distance of 260 pc yields a protostar surface density in the sub-clusters in the range
from 500-1100
.
To our knowledge, such a high spatial density of
protostars has not been found in any other nearby star formation region,
although we note that the Class 0 surface density in Orion-OMC3 is
comparable to that in the Serpens Core (Chini et al. 1997).
The sub-clustering in the observed 2D projection of the cluster does not
necessarily correspond to the true spatial distribution of the objects, but
it seems highly unlikely that these concentrations are due to elongated cloud
structures seen end-on. Sub-clustering was also found for the Class II
sources in
Ophiuchi (Bontemps et al. 2001), with a similar size scale as
for the Class II population in Serpens. It seems likely that the strong
clustering of Serpens protostars will evolve into looser clusters of
Class IIs over a few 106 yrs. The expansion of the clustering scales
from 0.12 to 0.25 pc and the assumed ages of these two populations
suggest that the velocity dispersion of the young stars is of the order of
only 0.05 km s-1.
![]() |
Figure 13:
The distribution of source separations for Class I and flat-spectrum
objects (circles) and Class II sources (dots). The number of
separations between sources (per bin) is plotted on the y-axis
as a function of separation in arc minutes on the x-axis. The
chosen bin size was 6 times the minimum separation, translating
to
|
| Open with DEXTER | |
Assuming that a recent burst of star formation took place
yrs ago, producing the current population of protostars, we can derive
a rough estimate of the star formation rate (SFR) and the star formation
efficiency (SFE) in this burst.
We use our sample of protostar candidates, the flat-spectrum and Class I
sources found clustered along the NW-SE oriented ridge. We are not able to
estimate their masses, but we hypothesize that they follow the same
IMF as the Class II sample. Comparing the total mass of the Class II
sample and correcting for the number of sources, we estimate a total mass
of
for the protostar population. If these sources were
formed gradually over
yrs, the SFR in this microburst
would be
/yr, or for typical masses of
,
one newborn star every
2800 yr. This SFR is
significantly higher than the one found for the whole YSO population
in
Ophiuchi (Bontemps et al. 2001).
Comparing the protostellar masses with the gaseous mass in these cores
will give us the star formation efficiency, defined as
.
According to Olmi & Testi (2002) the
two sub-clumps they name NW and SE, which contain our four sub-clusters of
protostars, are virialised with masses of 60
each. For our
protostar candidates this yields a SFE of about 9%.
This is the local SFE for the sub-clusters along the NW-SE ridge.
The global SFE calculated for the Class IIs and protostars over the entire
cluster (i.e. 28.8
of stellar mass) is much lower. In the
literature we find estimates of the total gas mass from 300
(McMullin et al. 2000) to 1500
(White et al. 1995) for surveyed areas of 5
to 10 arcmin, which gives only upper limits on the SFE of the order
of 2-9%.
The above estimates are based on the hypothesis that the protostars follow the same IMF as the one found for the Class II sources. We have not attempted to derive the protostar mass function. Future high resolution far-IR observations (e.g. ESA's Herschel Space Observatory) would be needed to yield bolometric luminosities of these clustered protostars, and with some assumptions on the accretion rates one could estimate their masses.
We have used ISOCAM to survey 0.13 square degrees of the Serpens Cloud
Core in two broad bands centred at 6.7 and 14.3
m. In combination
with our ground based deep JHK imaging of the 48 square arcmin
central region as well as additional K band imaging of about 30 square
arcmin to the NW, and a 1.3 mm IRAM map of the central dense filament,
we have investigated the mid-IR properties of the young stellar population.
The following results are found:
Casali et al. (1993) suggested that their submm sources without near-IR counterparts represented a second phase of active star formation in Serpens. Here we show the co-existence of sources in the various evolutionary stages from Class II and flat-spectrum to Class I and Class 0 sources. While we find an age estimate of 2 Myr for the Class II population, it is highly unlikely that the clustered Class I and flat-spectrum sources are older than a few 105 yrs. Our results therefore support the conclusions of Casali et al. (1993) that star formation has proceeded in several phases in Serpens.
Acknowledgements
The authors wish to thank Carlos Eiroa for stimulating discussions and helpful comments. We also thank an anonymous referee for comments that helped us improve the paper. The ISOCAM data presented in this paper were reduced using "CIA", a joint development by the ESA Astrophysics Division and the ISOCAM Consortium led by the ISOCAM PI, C. Cesarsky, Direction des Sciences de la Matière, C.E.A., France. The near-IR data presented in this paper were obtained with the ARcetri Near InfraRed CAmera ( ARNICA) at the Nordic Optical Telescope in 1996, and Carlo Baffa, Mauro Sozzi, Ruggero Stanga and Leonardo Testi from the ARNICA team are acknowledged for the instrument support. The Nordic Optical Telescope is operated on the island of La Palma jointly by Denmark, Finland, Iceland, Norway, and Sweden, in the Spanish Observatorio del Roque de los Muchachos of the Instituto de Astrofisica de Canarias. This publication made use of the SIMBAD database, operated at CDS, Strasbourg, France, and data products from the Two Micron All Sky Survey, which is a joint project of the University of Massachusetts and the Infrared Processing and Analysis Center/California Institute of Technology, funded by the National Aeronautics and Space Administration and the National Science Foundation. Financial support from the Swedish National Space Board is acknowledged.
At the location of IRAS 18269+0116 we find ISO-159 and ISO-160, of
which the latter is not detected at 14.3
m. A K-band image shows that
ISO-159 has a bow-shaped nebulosity
to WNW (at a level of about
3-4
,
see Fig. 4). The SED index classifies ISO-159 as a
flat-spectrum source, while ISO-160 is either an extremely extinguished
background source (analogous to CK2) or most likely a Class II object
(cf. Fig. 5).
Identified as a YSO by Clark (1991) on the basis of its steeply rising SED towards longer wavelengths. With ISOCAM we see two very bright point sources (221 and 238), of which only ISO-221 has IR-excess.
This source was suggested as a YSO on the basis of its location in the K vs
H-K diagram by Eiroa & Casali (1992). Deeper near-IR imaging detected the source
also in the J band, but found no near-IR excess (Kaas 1999a). It is
located in the very dense and active S68N region, but whether it has intrinsic
IR-excess at 7
m or is only reddened (in that case, by 3 mag in the
K band, which translates to
mag), is not clear.
Proposed as a YSO on the basis of its H-K colour and 3.08
m ice
feature (Eiroa & Casali 1992), but not found to have near-IR excess in a deeper
JHK study (Kaas 1999a), nor mid-IR excess in this study.
IRAS 18272+0114 is resolved into a cluster of protostar candidates: the
Deeply Embedded Outburst Source (Hodapp et al. 1996), EC37, EC38 and EC53
(Eiroa & Casali 1992), and three new ISOCAM sources (234, 237, 241). ISO-241 is
within the positional uncertainties associated with S68N, a radio source
detected by McMullin et al. (1994) and found to satisfy the Class 0 criteria.
We use the position at its 450
m emission peak (Wolf-Chase et al. 1998).
ISO-241 is a Class I, however, from the shape of its SED from 2 to 14
m. Hodapp (1999) denotes the K-band source SMM9-IR, since it is
located close to the SMM9 positions quoted in the literature
(Davis et al. 1999; Testi & Sargent 1998; Wolf-Chase et al. 1998; White et al. 1995), and shows that it has a very faint K
companion about
to the NE.
IRAS 18273+0113, also called FIRS1 and SMM1 (Casali et al. 1993; Rodriguez et al. 1989; Eiroa & Casali 1989), is
associated with 5 mid-IR excess sources (EC41, 253, 270, 276, 277) plus one
14.3
m source (258b).
ISO-Ser-258a is in agreement with the near-IR source positions of EC41
(Eiroa & Casali 1992) and GCNM23 (Giovannetti et al. 1998), and these are most likely the same
source, a Class I YSO according to the
index.
The ISOCAM source appeared slightly extended towards the SE both at 6.7
and 14.3
m in most of our data. Larsson et al. (2000) found evidence for two
separate sources, however, tracing pixel by pixel the 5 to 15
m SED
from CVF observations. This prompted us to take a more careful look, and
we identified two clearly separated sources at 14.3
m (rather than one
extended source) in one of the deeper (and higher resolution) survey maps,
D2 (cf. Fig. A.1). The new source (called 258b), is located about
to the SE of EC41. Since the radio position at RA(2000) = 18 29 49.73, Dec(2000) = 01 15 20.8 (Curiel et al. 1993) is
to the west of 258b we find it unlikely that this source is the mid-IR
counterpart of the far-IR source FIRS1, but it could be scattered light we
see in the mid-IR. It is not entirely clear if this source is just a knot of
the extended emission which appears to begin somewhat south of DEOS and is
seen in both filters in Fig. A.1. The northernmost part of this
extended emission is, however, disturbed by a memory feature from the strong
DEOS source in the raster scanning.
A prominent extended emission seen in the ISOCAM images corresponds in position
to IRAS 18273+0059 (Clark 1991). With ISOCAM, however, we see no apparent
bright point source embedded in the nebulosity, but a moderately faint object
is detected at 6.7
m only. On optical plates the SE part of this extended
emission is recognised as an optical reflection nebula.
IRAS 18274+0112 is also composed of multiple mid-IR excess sources centred
on SVS20 (cf. Fig. 12). Higher spatial 25
m resolution was
obtained by Hurt & Barsony (1996), and their sources PS1 and PS2 (EC129) are among
the bright mid-IR excess sources resolved with ISOCAM.
Included as a YSO candidate solely on the basis of its location in the K vs. H-K diagram (Eiroa & Casali 1992), and no near-IR excess found in a deeper JHK study (Kaas 1999a). Since we have no indication of mid-IR excess its status remains inconclusive.
This source (also called CK10) was suggested as a YSO on the basis of its
location in the K vs. H-K diagram (Eiroa & Casali 1992), and while near-IR excess
was found by Sogawa et al. (1997), no near-IR excess was found in a deeper JHK study
(Kaas 1999a). The J-band magnitude has varied though: 15.7 in 1989, 14.96
in May 1992, 15.6 in Nov. 1992, and 16.15 in Aug. 1996
(Giovannetti et al. 1998; Kaas 1999a; Sogawa et al. 1997; Eiroa & Casali 1992). We conclude that it isa YSO, and with an
it belongs in the Class II group.
ISO-317 is located at the position of EC92 according to the coordinates
given by Eiroa & Casali (1992), but the positional uncertainty is roughly
.
Also, the spatial resolution of ISOCAM is not sufficient to
resolve the two neighbours EC92 and EC95, and it is likely that both are
included in the ISOCAM fluxes. The mid-IR SED suggests a flat-spectrum
source. Slightly closer to the position of EC95, but also with some
positional uncertainty, Preibisch (1998) found an extremely strong X-ray
source (Ser-X3).
This bright mid-IR source is detectable in K as a nebulous spot only.
Probably the K flux is dominated by scattered light, and it is therefore
not entirely correct to place ISO-331 in colour diagrams together with
continuum sources. Nevertheless, the K measurement gives a lower limit to
the colour index of the object, which is classified as a Class I source.
Its mid-IR position is about 25
to the NNW of SMM2 (Casali et al. 1993),
and coincides roughly with the VLA 3.6 cm continuum source #11 found by
Bontemps (1996).
According to ISOCAM data the source CK2, which is extremely red in the
near-IR, has no mid-IR excess and can be interpreted as a background source,
consistent with the suggestions of Churchwell & Koornneef (1986), Chiar et al. (1994), Casali & Eiroa (1996)
and Sogawa et al. (1997). The extinction towards CK2 is high,
mag.