A&A 420, 527-532 (2004)
DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361:20040113
R. F. Viotti1 - L. A. Antonelli 2 - C. Rossi 3 - S. Rebecchi 4
1 - Istituto di Astrofisica Spaziale e Fisica Cosmica, CNR, Area di Ricerca Tor Vergata,
Via del Fosso del Cavaliere 100, 00133 Roma, Italy
2 -
INAF-Osservatorio Astronomico di Roma, Via di Frascati 33, 00040 Monte Porzio Catone, Roma, Italy
3 -
Dipartimento di Fisica, Università La Sapienza, Piazzale Aldo Moro 3, 00185 Roma, Italy
4 -
ASI Science Data Center (ASDC), c/o ESA-ESRIN, Via Galileo Galilei,
00044 Frascati, Roma, Italy
Received 27 December 2003 / Accepted 10 February 2004
Abstract
We report on the June 2000 long (100 ks) BeppoSAX exposure that unveiled
a new very high energy component of the X-ray spectrum
of
Car above 10 keV extending to at least 50 keV.
We find that the 2-150 keV spectrum is best reproduced
by a thermal + non-thermal model.
The thermal component dominates the 2-10 keV spectral
range with kTh = 5.5
0.3 keV and log NHh = 22.68
0.01.
The spectrum displays a prominent iron emission line centred
at 6.70 keV. Its equivalent width of 0.94 keV,
if produced by the thermal source, gives a slightly
sub-solar iron abundance ([Fe/H] = -0.15
0.02).
The high energy tail above 10 keV is best fitted by a power law
with a photon index of 2.42
0.04.
The integrated 13-150 keV luminosity of
12
is
comparable to that of the 2-10 keV thermal component (19
).
The present result can be explained,
in the
Car binary star scenario,
by Comptonisation of low frequency radiation by high energy
electrons, probably generated in the colliding wind shock front,
or in instabilities in the wind of the S Dor primary star.
It is possible that the high energy tail had
largely weakened near the minimum of the 5.53 yr cycle.
Probably, the thermal component has a longer recovery time like
that of the highest excitation optical emission lines.
Both features can be associated with the large absorption
measured by BeppoSAX at phase 0.05.
Key words: radiation mechanisms: non-thermal - stars: individual:
Car
- stars: winds, outflows - X-rays: stars
The peculiar southern object
Car
is one of the most remarkable variables in our Galaxy due to
the dramatic changes in its brightness.
In 1843 it was the second brightest star in the sky,
then decreased to the eighth magnitude by the end of the 19th century
(e.g. Viotti 1995).
During the last century
Car slowly and irregularly
re-brightened to the present
5.
According to the current distance estimates,
Car
has a bolometric magnitude around 5
106
(2
1040 erg s-1, e.g. Hillier et al. 2002).
A mass loss rate of 10-3/-4
yr-1
or larger has been estimated from observations
(e.g. Hillier et al. 2002; van Boekel et al. 2003;
Pittard & Corcoran 2002; Andriesse et al. 1978).
Optical spectroscopic observations unveiled a peculiar cyclic behaviour, showing regularly repeating excitation minima with a period of 5.53 years (Damineli et al. 2000). A similar behaviour was also found at other wavelength bands, from radio to X-rays, which is commonly interpreted in terms of a highly eccentric binary model composed of an S Dor-type very luminous primary star, and an unseen early type secondary star. The binary system interacts through colliding winds producing the observed high temperature luminous X-ray emission (e.g. Ishibashi et al. 1999; Corcoran et al. 2001).
Table 1: Summary of the BeppoSAX observations during 1996-2000. Phase one corresponds to the spectroscopic minimum of 1998.0.
Recently, thanks to the BeppoSAX unique broad-band X-ray
coverage we were able to detect, for the first time,
Car
above 10 keV (Viotti et al. 1998, 2002a, Paper I).
We reported the December 1996 observation showing
a 13-20 keV flux in excess of the extrapolated
5 keV thermal spectrum that dominates the 2-10 keV range.
The presence of a high energy tail was confirmed
by the following BeppoSAX observations of 31 December 1999-2 January 2000 (Rebecchi et al. 2001).
In particular, in June 2000 a 100 ks exposure showed
that the tail was probably non-thermal and extending to at
least 50 keV (Viotti et al. 2002b).
In this work we analyse in detail the latter observation
in order to investigate the origin of these very
high energy photons, and compare with the previous
BeppoSAX observations of
Car. The results are
summarised in Table 1.
![]() |
Figure 1:
The BeppoSAX MECS images of the |
| Open with DEXTER | |
The BeppoSAX satellite observed
Car on June 21-23, 2000
with its Narrow Field Instruments (NFI). NFI include a Low Energy
Concentrator Spectrometer (LECS) (Parmar et al. 1997), and three
Medium Energy Concentrator Spectrometers (MECS) (Boella et al.
1997) at the foci of four X-ray telescopes,
a Phoswich Detector System (PDS) (Frontera et al. 1997)
and a High Pressure Gas Scintillation Proportional Counter
(HPGSPC) (Manzo et al. 1997).
LECS and MECS units have imaging capabilities and cover
the 0.1-10 keV and 1.5-10 keV energy ranges, respectively.
PDS covers the 12-200 keV band, while HPGSP covers the 7-60 keV energy
range. They are both collimated instruments with a field of view of 1.3 and 1.1 degrees, respectively.
The PDS collimators are rocked back and forth by about 3
to allow the simultaneous monitoring of the source and background.
During 2000 HPGSP was switched off.
Car has been observed for a nominal exposure time of 100 ks.
The effective exposures were 80.8 ks for
MECS Nos. 2 and 3 (MECS No. 1 was not in operation),
and 33.4 ks for PDS. The corresponding count rates were,
MECS: 0.639
0.003, and PDS: 0.165
0.032 s-1.
The LECS image will not be discussed here,
as this paper is devoted to the analysis of the compact
hard component which dominates beyond
2 keV.
The observation date corresponds to phase 1.457 of the
spectral variation cycle of 5.53 yr (Damineli et al. 2000),
assuming
for the 1998.0 minimum.
Figure 1 shows the MECS images of the region around
Car
using photon events selected from three different energy bands,
in order to trace the softer and harder X-ray sources in the field
and to map the regions emitting in the 6.7 keV iron line.
It is evident in the figure that
Car is the hardest and most luminous object in the region.
Some other sources in the field present a non negligible residual
in the 7.5-10 keV range and at the iron line, the most interesting
one being the Wolf-Rayet star HD 93162/WR 25 (WN6+O4),
to the West of
Car.
This observation, in particular, shows that
Car is the
main, and, most probably, unique contributor to the flux
observed with the PDS instrument. As discussed in Paper I
the PDS field of view also includes the X-ray pulsar 1E 10148.1-5937; but, according to Oosterbroek et al. (1998)
and Tiengo et al. (2002) its spectrum is softer
and the flux above 10 keV is much fainter than that of
Car.
Also the lack of intense diffuse emission in the high energy MECS band
seems not to support the hypothesis of an extended very high energy
emission due to the interaction of the winds from the massive
stars in the Carina Nebula.
The MECS spectrum of
Car was extracted within a circular
region centred on the star with a radius of 4 arcmin.
To take into account possible contamination from the
nebular X-ray emission, we extracted the background
from a coronal region around
Car
with a 4.3 arcmin inner radius and 11.3 arcmin outer radius.
We also excluded from the selected area two circular areas
of 4 arcmin in radius centred on the strong
X-ray sources HD 93162 (WN6+O4) and HD 93250 (O3.5V).
The background-subtracted
spectrum of
Car and the local nebular spectrum
normalised to the same area are shown in Fig. 2.
The MECS background subtracted spectrum of
Car
has been rebinned in order to have at least 20 source
photons per energy bin.
The background-subtracted PDS data have been rebinned up to 50 keV following the standard procedure. Above 50 keV the data were
binned to have a 2
count rate in each bin.
As shown in Fig. 3,
Car is detected at the
3
level up to 45 keV, and at the 2
level
at higher energies.
Car had already been detected by PDS in December 1996
and December 1999, but only in the 13-20 keV range
due to the shorter exposure times.
A PDS upper limit was derived from the March 1998 observation.
Table 1 reports the 13-20 keV PDS count rates for the four
BeppoSAX observations.
![]() |
Figure 2:
The BeppoSAX MECS background-subtracted count rates
(in s-1 keV-1) of |
| Open with DEXTER | |
The extracted MECS+PDS spectrum of June 2000 was analysed
using the XSPEC spectral fitting software package.
We started by analysing MECS alone in the 2-10 keV energy
range which is dominated by the hard core component.
The MECS spectrum was first fitted with a thermal model (MEKAL)
leaving iron abundance free to vary.
We obtained the following best fit values of the parameters:
kTh= 5.51
0.25 keV,
NHh= 4.82
0.12
1022 cm-2, and
a logarithmic iron abundance of [Fe/H] = -0.15
0.02.
The reduced
was 1.749 (for 64 degrees of freedom),
partly due to the small
instrumental energy mismatch at 6.7 keV discussed in Paper I.
The source temperature is close to that measured in the MECS spectra of December 1996 and March 1998, and reported in Paper I.
In June 2000 the 2-10 keV energy distribution is
close to that of December 1996, with nearly the same NHh.
As discussed in Paper I, NHh was much larger in March 1998
during
Car's egress from the X-ray minimum event
(
;
see also Fig. 6 below).
As described in Paper I, we have also tried to model
the observed MECS spectrum using an absorbed
bremsstrahlung model and a Gaussian line.
We obtained for the iron line
a peak energy of 6.743
0.001 keV and an equivalent width
of 0.964 keV, with values for kTh (5.70
0.14)
and NHh ((4.91
0.10)
1022 cm-2) similar
to those derived from the previous MEKAL model.
As reported by Viotti et al. (2002b),
The equivalent width of the iron line is consistent with
that of December 1996 (1.05 keV) and of December 1999 (1.01 keV),
but smaller than that measured in March 1998 (see Table 1).
The peak energy of the line, corrected for the
+0.04 keV miscalibration discussed in Paper I,
suggests that the line is mostly emitted by the hot plasma, without
any important contribution from the 6.4 keV fluorescent line.
The reduced
was 1.96 in the range 2-10 keV.
The integrated absorbed and unabsorbed fluxes in the 2-10 keV
energy range are: fx= 6.45
10-11 erg cm-2 s-1and
fxo= 9.34
10-11 erg cm-2 s-1, respectively. The latter
corresponds to 19
for
Car's distance of 2.6 kpc.
![]() |
Figure 3: Upper panel: results of the fit of the June 2000 BeppoSAX MECS background-subtracted spectrum with a one-temperature (5.51 keV) MEKAL model. The spectral model is extrapolated to the PDS energy range to show the high energy flux excess. The residuals are plotted in the lower panel. |
| Open with DEXTER | |
Then, we analysed MECS and PDS simultaneously, allowing a PDS/MECS normalisation factor of 0.85, to take into account the miscalibration between the two instruments. This correcting factor was also used in Paper I, although it was not explicitly indicated. As shown in Fig. 3, PDS counts are well above the extrapolation to higher energies of the MECS best fit thermal model. The difference between observed and expected flux increases with energy, suggesting the presence of an additional very high energy component.
To account for the high energy tail, we tried
to fit the 2-150 keV spectrum with two thermal components.
However, the fit of MECS+PDS with two freely varying temperatures
always gives unrealistic results.
Therefore, we fit MECS+PDS with frozen kT(1) = 5.51 keV and
NH(1) = 4.82
1022 cm-2,
and constrain kT(2) to be close to 10 keV.
We thus derived: kT(2) = 14
5 keV, and
NH(2) = (543
22)
1022 cm-2,
with a reduced
of 2.33 (Fig. 4).
However, this result is not convincing, not only because
the fit runs below the observed flux above 30 keV,
but also because an unlikely very
high NH is required for the higher temperature component.
This suggests that the high energy spectrum of
Car
could be non-thermal.
![]() |
Figure 4:
Upper panel: results of the fit of the BeppoSAX MECS and PDS
(2-150 keV) spectrum of |
| Open with DEXTER | |
![]() |
Figure 5:
The BeppoSAX MECS and PDS (2-150 keV) spectrum of
|
| Open with DEXTER | |
Therefore, we tried to reproduce the 2-150 keV spectrum
with a combination of thermal bremsstrahlung (with frozen
kT = 5.70 keV) and power law components, having the same
absorption column density (4.82
1022 cm-2),
and a Gaussian line at 6.7 keV.
The best fit model is shown in Fig. 5.
The non-thermal component has a best fit photon index
of 2.42
.04 (reduced
2.41, for 79 d.o.f.).
If produced in a shock, this photon index would imply a
compression ratio for the shock front of
3.1, thus the
shock should be relatively weak (White & Chen 1994).
The nonthermal component in the 13-150 keV range has an
integrated energy flux of 5.51
10-11 erg cm-2 s-1 (11.6
),
a value comparable to that of the thermal 5 keV component.
We have also attempted to fit the overall MECS+PDS spectrum with
a single absorbed power law spectrum plus a Gaussian line.
Unexpectedly, quite a good fit was obtained (excluding the photon
events below 2 keV) with a best fit photon index of 2.467
0.024,
NH = (6.46
0.12)
1022, an Fe line centred at
6.733
0.007 keV, and a reduced
of 2.404.
However, this solution appears unrealistic,
in particular because it would imply that the iron emission
is mostly the 6.4 keV fluorescent line, in disagreement
with the measured peak energy of the feature
(
6.70
0.01 keV).
Therefore, the thermal plus power law model appears
more likely to us.
Incidentally, we notice that the two power law spectra have
nearly the same slope, independent of the energy range considered.
The high energy X-ray spectrum of
Car is challenging,
both because such an energetic and powerful
source has so far never been seen in any other star-like source
and no current model for non-thermal emission seems
applicable to the case of
Car.
In the
Car binary model it is assumed that the thermal
(5 keV) X-ray emission originates in the hot shocked gas produced
by collision between the winds of the two stellar components
(e.g. Pittard et al. 1998; Ishibashi et al. 1999).
The shocked region should be placed at a distance
from a few to many AU from the surface of the S Dor star
during the highly eccentric orbital motion of the system.
In this model, the plasma temperature is linked to the wind
velocities, and would be unable to produce directly
the highest energy photons seen in
Car.
The power law spectrum exhibited by
Car above 10 keV
indicates the presence of an additional non-thermal source.
In principle, non-thermal emission can be explained by several
physical processes, most of which are, however, barely
compatible with current models of
Car.
A plausible, but still difficult to accept process would be inverse
Compton scattering (IC) of low frequency photons by high energy
electrons. In the case of
Car a powerful photon source
could be represented by the intense
ultraviolet radiation from the stellar components
of the binary system, probably from the hot secondary,
since most likely the UV photons from the S Dor primary do not
emerge from its dense wind.
Stellar UV photons scattered by relativistic electrons would
finally emerge with energies in the X- and
-ray
range, and may carry away much of the energy pumped
into the electrons at shocks.
This process would require the presence of relativistic
electrons with
.
According to White (1985) and Chen & White (1991)
in the winds of early-type stars electrons
can be accelerated to relativistic energies
via the first-order Fermi mechanism in strong isothermal shocks
generated by radiation-driven instabilities in the wind.
On the other hand, Jardine et al. (1996)
have shown that in a colliding wind binary
system, electrons can be accelerated up to relativistic energies
in a current sheet, formed when the magnetic fields carried in
the stellar winds are forced together as the winds collide.
In the case of
Car there is no direct or indirect
evidence of the presence of very high energy electrons.
Indirect evidence could be non-thermal radio emission,
like that detected in galactic and extragalactic high energy
X-ray sources. However, non-thermal radio emission centred
on
Car's stellar core has not been detected
although we cannot exclude its presence.
Were it present, it would lie below the surface that is
optically thick due to free-free emission,
and the whole central region of
Car is optically
thick in radio wavelengths to out several arcseconds.
Since the non-thermal emission should not extend
that far away from the shock, it should be completely
hidden by the thermal emission from the dense ionised stellar winds
(Stephen White, priv. comm.).
One should also consider that, as recently discussed by Dougherty
et al. (2003), in colliding wind binary systems the
non-thermal radio emission could be weakened by self-absorption
and inverse Compton cooling.
Non-thermal radio emission has been detected in a number
of massive binaries, suggesting the presence of relativistic
electrons with power-law spectra, which could result in hard
X- and
-ray non-thermal flux via IC scattering
(e.g. Benaglia & Romero 2003).
Among them, the WR+O binary system WR 140 bears some resemblance
to the
Car system for its long period (7.9 yr), and
high orbital eccentricity (e.g. Marchenko et al. 2003),
and for the presence of a variable IR excess attributed to
dust formation near periastron (e.g. Williams et al. 1987).
The X-ray emission of WR 140 is one order of magnitude smaller
than that of
Car, but, like
Car, it suffers a strong
absorption excess near phases 0.03 and 0.08 (Zhekov & Skinner 2000).
If the physical process of production of non-thermal radio
emission (that is of high energy electrons) in WR 140 is also
working in
Car, we would expect from
Car a very
strong non-thermal radio emission. As discussed above,
its absence is probably due to the heavy obscuration
by the thermal absorption from the dense stellar winds.
Indeed, the crucial point of the spectrum
Car's core
radio emission remains unsolved.
Self-Comptonisation is a mechanism proposed to explain
non-thermal emission in AGNs, as well as in galactic
compact X-ray sources.
As for instance discussed by Hua & Titarchuk (1995),
quasi-power law X-ray spectra can be produced by diffusion
of low frequency photons by optically thick relativistic
plasma clouds. In this framework,
we might assume that the spectrum of
Car above 10 keV
is produced by scattering of the 5 keV thermal radiation itself
by high energy (>10 keV) electrons present
in the shocked region.
This seems to us a more promising process as it does not require
highly relativistic electrons as in the IC case.
The study of the spectral variability along the 5.53 yr cycle
could be a complementary way to tackle the problem of
the origin of the high energy X-ray tail of
Car.
Table 1 reports the PDS count rates
and the best fit parameters of the thermal component
during the four BeppoSAX observations.
We recall that, according to the RossiXTE observations,
in December 1997
Car underwent a deep X-ray eclipse,
which is currently associated with the periastron passage
of the suggested binary system (Ishibashi et al. 1999).
The X-ray eclipse lasted until the end of February 1998.
Hence, the BeppoSAX observation of mid March 1998
was made during
Car's egress from the eclipse.
Figure 6 compares the BeppoSAX MECS spectra observed during the four epochs. For the sake of homogeneity with the other observations, only MECS units 2 and 3 have been considered for the December 1996 spectrum. It is evident in the figure that beyond the iron feature the four spectra nearly overlap, also suggesting that the highly absorbed March 1998 spectrum had about the same temperature and unabsorbed flux as in the other three epochs.
In three cases the PDS count rate
in the 13-20 keV range was the same within the data uncertainty.
As shown in Table 1, in March 1998
Car was not detected
with PDS. The 3
upper limit of 0.15 s-1 is equal
to the flux measured in the other three observations,
but we think that this coincidence is accidental,
and that in March 1998 the high energy tail was weak.
Most probably, this component followed the trend of the
thermal one, and greatly weakened during the
1998.0 X-ray eclipse.
Our March 1998 observation suggests that,
while the thermal component had already recovered
its luminosity, although with a large residual absorption,
the high energy tail was still weak.
It should have recovered its luminosity at a later time
(but well before phase 1.37).
It may be noticed that a long recovering time was also found
in the visual spectrum for the high excitation emission lines
(e.g. [Ne III]), which, as discussed in Paper I,
were still very weak in May 1998.
The limited time-coverage does not allow us to conclude
whether there is a physical link between the two phenomena,
but it would be worthwhile investigating this in the future.
![]() |
Figure 6:
Plot of the BeppoSAX MECS23 spectra of |
| Open with DEXTER | |
We have presented the first in-depth analysis of the spectrum
of the
Car system above 10 keV, based on a long exposure
BeppoSAX observation. The power law best fit suggests a
non-thermal origin of the hard X-ray tail.
The integrated 13-150 keV luminosity (
12
)
is comparable
to the luminosity of the 2-10 keV thermal component (19
),
and suggests the presence of a very effective formation process.
Two models have been considered in the light of the proposed
binary nature of
Car.
In one model the high energy tail is produced by inverse Compton
scattering of the UV stellar photons by relativistic
electrons produced in the wind of the primary star, or
in the shocked colliding wind region.
Alternatively, the high energy photons are produced by
self-Comptonisation of the thermal 5 keV emission from relativistic
electrons with energies much lower than in the previous case.
However, the weakness of the high energy tail in March 1998
could be better explained as high inverse Compton cooling
of the relativistic electrons during periastron passage,
when the colliding wind shock is closer to the stars.
Neither model has enough support from observations, such as the
detection of non-thermal radio emission from the central source, a
point which would require new very high resolution radio observations.
A crucial point for understanding the nature of the high energy tail
of
Car is to investigate the slope of the spectrum
at higher energies and to measure the high energy cutoff
which is related to the energy of the scattering particles.
Our PDS observations allow us to determine a lower limit to the cutoff
energy of
50 keV. INTEGRAL observations might allow measurement
of the X-ray spectrum of
Car above 100 keV, and to determine
up to what energy the power law spectrum extends.
Finally, new high energy (>10 keV) X-ray observations,
e.g. with the proposed ASTRO-E satellite,
of
Car near the periastron passage of the system will
provide a clue to where the non-thermal source is located.
Our March 1998 upper limit might suggest a recovery
time slower than that of the thermal source, as observed
in the optical spectra in the high energy emission lines.
It would important to investigate the physical link
beteen the two phenomena, and whether that behaviour is associated
with the high NHh value found also at the eclipse egress.
Acknowledgements
We are grateful to the other BeppoSAX team members at ASDC for help in acquiring and reducing the data. Thanks are due to L. Piro, V. F. Polcaro and Stephen White for discussions, and to the anonymous referee for constructive suggestions. This work is partly based on contract I/R/053/02 of the Italian Space Agency (ASI).