A&A 376, 553-560 (2001)
DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361:20010979
B. Nisini1 - F. Massi2 - F. Vitali1 - T. Giannini1 - D. Lorenzetti1 - A. Di Paola1 - C. Codella3 - F. D'Alessio1 - R. Speziali1
1 - Osservatorio Astronomico di Roma, 00040 Monteporzio Catone,
Italy
2 -
Osservatorio Astronomico di Collurania-Teramo, Via M. Maggini, 64100 Teramo, Italy
3 -
CNR-Istituto di Fisica dello Spazio Interplanetario,
Area di Ricerca Tor Vergata, Via Fosso del Cavaliere 100, 00133 Roma, Italy
Received 13 March 2001 / Accepted 5 July 2001
Abstract
We present near infrared images of the bright rimmed globule
IC 1396-N in the H2 2.12
m narrow band filter as well as
in
broad band J, H and K filters. We detected several
chains of collimated H2 knots inside the globule, having
different luminosities but similar orientations in the sky. Most of the
knots are associated with peaks of high velocity CO emission, indicating
that they trace shocked regions along collimated stellar jets.
From the H2 knots morphology and
orientation, we identify at least three different jets: one
of them is driven by the young protostar associated with IRAS 21391+5802,
which represents the most luminous object
in the region, while we were able to identify only one of
the two other driving sources by means of near infrared
photometry.
Our photometry reveals the existence of a cluster of young
embedded sources located in a south-north line which follows the
distribution of the high density gas and testifies for a highly
efficient star formation activity through all the globule.
Key words: stars: formation - ISM: jets and outflows - ISM: individual objects: IC 1396-N - infrared: ISM: lines
IC 1396 is an
extended H II region
located in the Cep OB2 association (at a distance of 750 pc) and excited by the
O6 star HD 206267. Inside the ionised region,
several globules have been identified, characterised by their
optically visible
bright rim tracing the ionisation front in the direction of the O6 star
(Osterbrock 1957).
Such globules have long been suspected to be sites of star formation
induced by the compression due to the ionisation shock front.
The association of some of these globules with IRAS sources has given
further support to this hypothesis (Sugitani et al. 1991).
IC 1396-N, located at about 11 pc of projected distance from HD 206267,
is associated with the brightest of these IRAS sources
(21391+5802,
,
e.g. Wilking et al. 1993)
showing a very cold far infrared spectrum and a large circumstellar mass
(Wilking et al. 1993; Sugitani et al. 2000), indicating that it should be in an
early stage of evolution. Furthermore this source drives an energetic outflow
having a dynamical time <105 yr (Sugitani et al. 1989;
Codella et al. 2001).
These findings represent strong evidence for an on-going star
formation activity triggered by radiation-driven implosion,
although evidences
for a spontaneous onset of the collapse are also provided
(Serabyn et al. 1993).
IC 1396-N has been recently also observed with the ISO spectrometers.
The far-infrared spectrum from the environments of the IRAS source is
extremely rich of
molecular emission excited at a temperature in excess of 1500 K
(Saraceno et al. 1996) in a dense shock originated along the
protostellar outflow.
Such a high temperature is expected to give rise also to copious
emission from the rotovibrational transitions of H2 and in
particular from the 1-0 S(1) line at 2.12
m.
In this paper we report the results of narrow band imaging in this
line covering all the IC 1396-N globule. These observations provide a
powerful tool both to study the morphology of the shocked gas and
to indirectly reveal the presence of young embedded sources
inside the globule.
The narrow band images are also complemented with J, H and
K photometry
of the region, allowing to study the young star
population and test the hypothesis of the triggered star
formation.
The narrow-band H2 images were
obtained on August 19 and September 30, 1999 along with images of the
standard star HD 203856 (Elias et al. 1982).
The total integration time in the narrow band filter was 40 min per image.
J,H and K images were acquired on August 18, 1999, September 30, 1999 and
August 30, 2000. The integration times for these images were
11 min in the K band and 5 min in the J and H bands, allowing
sensitivity limits (at 3
)
of
J = 18.4, H = 17.6 and K = 16.3 mag. We estimated a
completeness limit of 15 mag in the K band.
Flux calibration of the continuum images was made
by means of
observations of the IR standard stars AS35, AS 37-1 and AS37-0 (Hunt et al.
1998).
Differential flat-field frames were obtained through
images of the illuminated dome or the sky at setting.
Data reduction was performed using IRAF routines and included
flat-field correction and subtraction of a sky frame
constructed by combining different on-sky images through a
median filtering. Photometry on the observed fields
was performed through PSF-fitting using DAOPHOT in IRAF.
Aperture corrections
were estimated by accurately studying the growth curves both
of bright isolated field stars and of the standard stars themselves.
Seeing ranged from
2 to
3 arcsec, whereas zero point
variations of
0.1 mag were found in the photometry
of the standard stars before and after the field observations. These
are of the same order of the zero point variations found in
a same frame when more than 1 standard star are imaged.
The astrometric calibration was obtained by using stars
recognisable both in our frames and in the Palomar Digitized Sky
Survey (DSS). The resulting accuracy is within 1 arcsec.
Figure 1 shows the region covered by our mosaic on a
DSS image; the bright rim underlining the dark globule is clearly
visible. Figure 2 shows the K image of the central region of the
globule; a number of infrared sources are located inside the
optically dark region, together with patches of nebulosity and
extended emission. The source IRAS 21391+5802 is marked with a cross and
its uncertainty ellipse is also overlaid.
The bright rim structure is still visible also at 2
m.
Figure 3 shows the H2 2.12
m plus continuum emission
in the investigated field. The figure is a mosaic of three different
images (see Fig. 1), covering a total area of about 44 arcmin2.
An image of the pure H2 emission has been constructed by subtracting the broad-band K image to the narrow-band image after having corrected for the different integration times and filters characteristics.
Figure 4 shows the result of this subtraction in the region of the mosaic where the H2 emission has been detected. The position of IRAS 21391+5802 is marked with an asterisk. Several jets of H2 emission are present all over the image and seem to trace different flows; we have labelled the most prominent emission knots from A to G giving their position and luminosity in Table 1.
|
|
|
|||
| A | 21:39:12 | 58:02:38 | 0.025 | 2.3 |
| B | 21:39:24 | 58:02:59 | 0.026 | 0.73 |
| C | 21:39:03 | 58:04:40 | 0.036 | 1.0 |
| F | 21:39:10 | 58:04:58 | 0.008 | 0.22 |
| E | 21:39:04 | 58:03:58 | 0.005 | 0.14 |
| D | 21:39:14 | 58:04:02 | 0.006 | 0.17 |
| G | 21:39:06 | 58:03:17 | 0.004 | 0.11 |
![]() |
Figure 1:
|
| Open with DEXTER | |
![]() |
Figure 2: K image of the central region of the globule (corresponding to the thickest frame in Fig. 1). The cross indicates the position of the IRAS source for which also the uncertainty ellipse is delineated. Right ascension and declination are at 1950. |
| Open with DEXTER | |
![]() |
Figure 3:
H2 2.12 |
| Open with DEXTER | |
In principle, H2 excitation inside the globule could be
due either to shocks driven by the outflows of young stellar
objects or to fluorescence induced by the UV photons from
the external ionised region. The jet-like morphology
of the H2 emission knots and their location in different
parts of the globule
and not just on the bright rim, can be considered an indication more
in favour of shocked gas along stellar jets. A more quantitative
analysis to establish how much of the observed emission could be
attributed to fluorescent excitation can be done by estimating the
FUV field associated with the ionising front.
The far infrared spectra
obtained by ISO-LWS (with a FOV of about 80
)
provide a
measure of the [C II]158
m
line brightness of
erg s-1 cm-2 sr-1, almost constant
in three different positions of the globule (Saraceno,
private communication).
This value translates into a FUV flux of
120 G0,
where
erg s-1 cm-2 is a measure of the average local
interstellar field (Habing 1968), adopting the relationship
G0 erg s-1 cm-2 sr-1 (Hollenbach et al. 1991).
The H22.12
m intensity produced by fluorescence
in a photo-dissociation region with this field is expected to be
lower than 10-5 erg s-1 cm-2 sr-1 for densities <106 cm-3
(e.g. Burton et al. 1992).
The observed knots show H2 intensities between 10 and 100
times larger than this value, thus excluding fluorescent emission as the
main mechanism for their excitation. On the other hand, non-dissociative
shocks with velocities larger than
20 km s-1 can easily produce the
observed strength of the 2.12
m line.
In order to better clarify this interpretation, we have compared
our H2 image with a map of the high velocity CO J=2-1emission taken from Codella et al. (2001). Figure 5
shows the two maps superimposed each other; the solid
and dashed contours refer to the blue- and the red-shifted gas respectively.
As discussed in Codella et al., the CO emission detected in the
globule clearly presents a double component; a low velocity gas
delineating the globule structure and probably put into motion by the
action of the external radiation field, and high velocity,
(up to 40km s-1), bipolar components which are clearly associated with
outflowing gas from young stellar objects.
Most of the H2 knots are associated with these high velocity CO peaks, thus
reinforcing the interpretation of shock excitation.
From this figure it clearly appears that the two clumps A and B are
associated with the more extended outflow emanating from the IRAS
source, which was originally discovered by Sugitani et al. (1989)
(here called outflow I).
The H2 knot A is close to the IRAS position
and associated with both a blue and a red CO peak. Knot B is
located towards a second CO peak of blueshifted emission, which is
extended eastward. The red part of the flow is less extended and
collimated; here the outflow seems to bend towards north as it
interacts with the wall of the globule. No H2 emission is
observed from this red lobe, due either to a higher extinction
(a value of
35 mag would be required
in order not to detect H2 emission of the same strength as the
blue lobe), or to a much lower pre-shock density encountered by the flow,
producing a weaker shock interaction.
![]() |
Figure 4:
Continuum subtracted H2 2.12 |
| Open with DEXTER | |
Two additional outflows can be tentatively identified from the comparison of the CO and the H2 maps. Considering only the H2knots morphology and alignments, one would be tempted to assume that knots C and F belong to the blue and red-shifted parts of the same outflow, in which case knots D and E would define a third outflow aligned perpendicularly to it. However, a 1.3 millimeter continuum map of this northern region of the globule (Codella et al. 2001), reveals a peak of emission just at the center of the axis connecting knots D and C, suggesting the presence of a cold source which could excite these shock condensations. Therefore D and C are probably associated with the two lobes of the same flow (outflow III) while an additional flow (outflow II) could be associated with knots F and E. These two outflows present a more compact structure and a weaker CO emission with respect to outflow I. Knot C has an H2intensity comparable to knots A and B (see Table 1), while the intensity of knot D can be weaker due to its association with redshifted gas and thus with larger extinction regions. On the other hand, knots E and F are both fainter than the other clumps, indicating presumably a weaker shock interaction (see also next section). Finally, the knot labelled as G in the H2 image cannot be easily associated with any of the CO peaks although it is clearly located in a region of enhanced high-velocity CO emission.
It is remarkable that all the three identified jets are oriented
with a position angle of about 80
with respect to the
North. This preferred orientation strongly resemble the orientation
shown by the
magnetic field lines on the border of externally illuminated globules
as observed by Hodapp (1987). The explanation given for such orientation
is that in the outer parts of
the globule the magnetic field is aligned by the wind or radiation
effects coming from the centre of the HII region; the outflows will
be then aligned with the magnetic field direction.
![]() |
Figure 5:
Continuum subtracted H2 2.12 |
| Open with DEXTER | |
The good spatial coincidence of the H2 knots with the peaks of high-velocity CO integrated emission gives support to the idea that the observed H2 emission originates in the shocks occurring at the head of a collimated stellar jet when it interacts with the ambient molecular gas; in this scenario the shock causes the ambient gas to be swept up at large distances from the jet itself (Masson & Chernin 1993; Raga & Cabrit 1993).
From Table 1 we can have an estimate of the total H2 energy
radiated away by each of the detected shock events, assuming that
the S(1) line represents about 1/10 of the radiation emitted by
H2 in all the
rotovibrational lines; this is a valid approximation for a
thermalised gas at about 2000 K. The so found total luminosity
needs to be corrected for the 2.12
m extinction which can be
severe especially for the knot A which is located close to the highly
embedded IRAS source. Indeed, from millimeter maps of the central
region of IC 1396-N, visual extinction values as high
as
mag can be inferred in the direction of the exciting source
(Wilking et al. 1993; Sugitani et al. 2000).
Knot A is at about 20
away from the millimeter
peak and it is expanding in a direction of decreasing column
density.
If we scale the clump column density according to the density profile
derived by Serabyn et al. (1993), we can infer a visual extinction of about 20 mag
in the direction of knot A. Assuming this visual extinction,
the intrinsic total H2 luminosity becomes 2.3
.
For knot B, as well as for the other H2 emission knots,
we assume a lower extinction value of 10 mag, which is the average
extinction derived from the color-color diagram shown in Fig. 6
by looking at the location
of the sources having reddened main sequence colors.
In Table 1, the so derived
intrinsic luminosities are reported for each knot.
In addition to H2, a significant contribution to the cooling of
the post shocked gas is expected from other molecules and atoms, such as
O I, CO and H2O (i.e. Kaufman & Neufeld 1996). Indeed, the
observations carried out by the Infrared Space Observatory towards
IRAS 21391+5802
have detected strong emission from these species whose total cooling
amount to about 0.9
(Saraceno et al. 1996; Nisini et al.
1998).
This represents one third of the H2 luminosity derived here for
clump A, which is also encompassed by the ISO spectrometer field of
view.
We can assume that the same ratio also applies for the other observed
knots of shocked emission. In this way, we can have an estimate of the
total cooling in the post-shocked gas (
), which,
if the shock is fully radiative, can be expressed as:
![]() |
(1) |
![]() |
(2) |
If we consider the entire outflow I, its total shock radiated luminosity
+
is about 4
.
This
value is much higher than the
value estimated from the CO mapping
(0.15-1.2
Codella et al. 2001). Since
and
are expected to be roughly equal if the CO molecular outflow is
accelerated
at the shock front with momentum conservation (Davis &
Eislöffel 1995), the difference in these two values may
indicate that the outflow inclination angle is actually smaller
than the 10
-20
assumed for the derivation of
.
We also remark that the ratio
/
is about 10-2,
which is the value expected for Class 0 protostars given
the relationship between these two quantities found by Giannini
et al. (2001) (see next section).
In Fig. 4 we have indicated with crosses the reddest sources in the field (see Sect. 3.4), in order to identify the possible exciting sources of the observed H2 jets.
With regard to the outflow I associated with jets A and B, Codella
et al. (2001) show that the exciting source has to be identified with
a continuum radio source located close to the IRAS
position.
This object is not associated with any near infrared
counterpart at a K magnitude level of 16.3 mag. This is
somehow expected,
since the IRAS source has a very steep spectrum with a flux
dropping from 145 Jy at 60
m to 0.56 Jy at 12
m. In
fact Wilking et al. (1993), who obtained the photometry from 1.6
to 20
m of the sources located around the IRAS position,
find one object within the IRAS error ellipse detected only
longward to 3.5
m.
Given the highly embedded nature of the IRAS counterpart,
it should be extremely young. An estimate of its age can be given by assuming
it equal to the dynamical age of its outflow.
The clump B lies at about 0.45 pc from the IRAS source.
Assuming a jet velocity of
40 kms-1, the implied dynamical time
is
yrs; allowing for an outflow inclination
of up to 20
(Codella et al. 2001), this time drops to
yrs.
For the closer knot (A)
is about only 104 yrs.
Ages from 104 yrs to 105 yrs are typical of Class 0 sources
(André et al. 2000).
To check for the real membership to this class, we have taken the submillimeter
fluxes observed in this source from Saraceno et al. (1996) and estimated
the ratio
/
,
where
is the luminosity emitted
longward of 350
m. In Class 0 sources this ratio must be larger than
,
a value which implies
that the envelope mass is
than the stellar mass (André et al. 2000).
For IRAS 21391
this ratio is
for
,
ensuring that this
object is a "true''
Class 0 source. It is significant that very few Class 0 of luminosity as high as
IRAS 21391
have been so far observed (see, e.g., the list in André et al. 2000).
The fact to observe one of such high luminosity objects
associated with the IC 1396-N globule may be an indication in favour of the
suggestion by Sugitani et al. (1991) that star formation by radiative
implosion has a greater efficiency in the production of intermediate-mass stars.
Codella et al. (2001) identify the exciting star of outflow III
in a millimeter source located at the geometrical
center of the outflow. Two infrared sources are present close to
this millimeter peak (labelled as (a) and (b) in Fig. 4)
both of them with red colors (H-K
2, J-H > 2.8) and
similar K magnitude (13.6 and 13.2 mag).
Given their similar near IR magnitudes and distance from the
millimeter source, we cannot uniquely distinguish which of the
two is the outflow driving source, although source (b) is preferred
given its exact location on the symmetric axis of the flow.
A bolometric luminosity of about 10
is estimated for
this source from the millimeter continuum data (Codella et al. 2001).
| # | K( |
H- K( |
J- H( |
Notes1 | ||
| 1 | 21:39:06.9 | 58:03:57 | 15.808(0.123) | >1.792 | ... | |
| 2 | 21:39:07.5 | 58:02:29 | 15.143(0.162) | >2.457 | ... | |
| 3 | 21:39:07.7 | 58:04:52 | 13.188 (0.048) | 2.032 (0.08) | >3.18 | source (b) |
| 4 | 21:39:08.2 | 58:03:05 | 15.878(0.149) | >1.722 | ... | |
| 5 | 21:39:08.2 | 58:04:44 | 13.592(0.041) | 1.958 (0.080) | >2.850 | source (a) |
| 6 | 21:39:08.8 | 58:03:12 | 13.875(0.054) | 1.597 (0.082) | >2.928 | |
| 7 | 21:39:08.8 | 58:02:31 | 13.023(0.083) | 3.130 (0.131) | >2.247 | IRS2 of W93 |
| 8 | 21:39:09.2 | 58:02:57 | 12.283(0.059) | 2.820 (0.089) | >3.297 | |
| 9 | 21:39:11.2 | 58:03:36 | 15.307(0.110) | >2.293 | ... | |
| 10 | 21:39:11.5 | 58:02:38 | 13.363(0.066) | >4.237 | ... | IRS3 of W93 |
| 11 | 21:39:12.7 | 58:02:25 | 12.773(0.038) | 1.597 (0.054) | 2.275 (0.109) | IRS4 of W93 |
| 12 | 21:39:13.5 | 58:02:46 | 14.608(0.155) | 1.678 (0.183) | >2.118 | |
| 13 | 21:39:13.8 | 58:02:00 | 15.357(0.143) | >2.243 | ... | |
| 14 | 21:39:15.1 | 58:02:01 | 15.045(0.086) | 1.857 (0.197) | >1.498 | |
| 15 | 21:39:15.2 | 58:03:20 | 15.282(0.136) | >2.318 | ... | |
| 16 | 21:39:15.2 | 58:02:57 | 14.502(0.057) | 1.573 (0.097) | >2.325 | IRS5 of W93 |
| 17 | 21:39:16.5 | 58:02:20 | 11.716 (0.023) | 1.516 (0.030) | 2.286(0.037) | IRS6 of W93 |
| 18 | 21:39:23.0 | 58:02:51 | 15.814(0.144) | >1.786 | ... | |
| 19 | 21:39:25.1 | 58:03:01 | 14.381(0.124) | 1.681 (0.151) | 1.392 (0.143) | |
| 20 | 21:38:55.9 | 58:02:57 | 14.921(0.118) | >2.679 | ... |
As regards the other flow (outflow II), a careful inspection of
the K image does not allow to identify a possible
candidate for the exciting source. No sources
are indeed located at the center of the flows or on the outflow
axis. This may suggest that these knots are excited by a very
embedded object. Assuming the same velocity as the
outflow I, outflow II seems to have dynamical timescales of
about
yrs, pointing also in this case to the
presence of a young protostar.
![]() |
Figure 6:
Color-color diagram of the stars in
|
| Open with DEXTER | |
In Fig. 6, the J-H, H-K color-color diagram for the
sources in the field centred on the IRAS position is shown. The solid
curve is the locus of the unreddened main sequence stars, while the
two dashed
lines are parallel to the reddening vector and define the band
of the reddened normal stellar photosphere. On the right of
this band are young sources with intrinsic infrared excesses.
In this figure, open squares indicate sources with valid
detections in all three bands, upper arrows indicate sources
with un upper limit in the J band, while small vertical
segments with rightward arrows indicate sources with
a valid detection only in the K band; for these latter, a
random J-H color have been assigned to position them on
the diagram.
From the figure it appears that a large fraction of
sources are located outside the reddening band, testifying the
presence of an embedded young cluster associated with the
cloud; this is also evidenced by the averaged large (
10 mag)
extinction inferred from the diagram.
Following Lada & Adams (1992), young stars with colors in a
box of about 0.5 mag centred on J-H, H-K
1 belong
to pre-main sequence Classical T Tauri (CTT) stars, while
sources with redder colors are less evolved Class I type
objects.
In Table 2, we report the position and the magnitudes of the
reddest
sources in the field, (J-H, H-K
mag) believed
to be the youngest of the cluster. Some of these sources were
already discovered by Wilking et al. (1993) and are indicated in
the table. From this table and
from Fig. 4, where the spatial position of these sources is
indicated by crosses on the H2 image of the region, we can see
that they form a cluster around the IRAS source position, while
some of them
(including sources (a) and (b), which are associated with the
northen outflow)
are also located further north of the cloud rim.
Sugitani et al. (1989) suggested that star formation inside bright rimmed globules is induced by the propagation of the H II ionisation front with the consequent compression due to the radiation pressure. In support to this hypothesis Sugitani et al. (1995) noticed that in different globules in which near IR photometry has been performed, there is a tendency for the young stars to be preferentially distributed along the symmetric axis of the globule towards the direction of the external exciting star; moreover the older stars appear located very close to the bright rim while the redder sources are situated close to the IRAS source which usually appears as the youngest star of the cluster. This distribution suggests a propagation of the star formation from the rim to the interior of the globule as the result of the advancing perturbation induced by the ionisation front.
If we look at the distribution of the young sources in IC 1396-N, we can notice that the young star population is mainly located along a south-north line roughly following the symmetric axis of the globule as found by Sugitani et al. (1995) in similar clouds. We also remark that the young stars appear to cluster along the density distribution inside the globule as evidenced by the CS 3-2 map by Codella et al. (2001). However there is not a clear evidence for an age distribution going from the rim to the globule interior and it is therefore difficult to conclude that the present star formation activity is induced by the ionisation front just on the basis of the source distribution.
H2 narrow band imaging of the
IC 1396-N globule reveals the presence of several H2 jets inside the
optically dark region.
Such jets are closely associated with CO peaks of high
velocity gas. The intrinsic H2 luminosity of these emission knots
is high (0.1-2.3
)
compared with typical
luminosities observed in H2 jets from young stars (Davis
& Eislöffel 1995), indicating that they trace
particularly energetic mass ejections. From an analysis of
the total radiated shock
luminosity in each knot, we estimate that the observed H2emission originates from non-dissociative shocks with velocities
from 25 to 40 km s-1.
The short dynamical time exhibited by the jets
(<
yrs) and the confirmed membership of the
IRAS source to the poor evolved Class 0 protostars
indicate that the H2 emission is associated with
the most embedded and youngest objects of the field.
The near infrared photometry confirms the existence of a
cluster of young embedded sources, located
along the south-north direction and following the distribution of
the high density gas, thus testifying for a highly efficent star formation
activity. The present observations do not however present clear evidences
in favour of a triggered mechanism due to the ionisation front.
Acknowledgements
We thanks the referee for her/his valuable comments on the first version of this paper.